Minna’s 37 and the failure of custody

Thirty-seven Nigerians are dead. Not killed in crossfire, not lost to an accident, but suffocated, dehydrated, and abandoned inside a cell run by an agency of the Nigerian state. Among them were teenagers. Among them were internally displaced persons who had already lost their homes to insurgency before they lost their lives to a government detention facility. This is not a tragedy in the passive sense the word usually implies. It is the direct, foreseeable, and entirely preventable consequence of official cruelty and indifference and it must be named as such.

The facts, as they have emerged through Nigeria Security and Civil Defence Corps (NSCDC) own admissions, survivors’ testimony, and the account of Niger State’s governor, are damning. Sixty-six people were crushed into a single cell built for a fraction of that number. They begged for water and were ignored. They reportedly drank their own urine to survive. A survivor now alleges that an unidentified substance was sprayed into the room, causing people to cough and choke. Officers watched this happened and, by their own account, dismissed the desperate cries of dying men as lies. Then, in the initial hours after the deaths became public, the Corps reached for the most convenient untruth available: disease. Only under public pressure did that story collapse into what any honest observer suspected from the outset: this was not an outbreak of illness. This was an outbreak of official brutality.

There is no operational justification, no policy objective, no war on illegal mining important enough to warrant the mass suffocation of the people entrusted to a government agency’s custody. These were not convicted criminals. Many were young men trying to survive in a country that has given them no better option. Whatever their alleged offence, none of them was sentenced to die of heat and thirst behind a locked door. Nobody, not a commandant, not a minister, not a president has the right to take the life of anybody, and certainly not through the slow, cruel arithmetic of overcrowding and neglect.

What is equally condemnable is how this was handled in its immediate aftermath. The instinct of the NSCDC leadership was not transparency but containment: a vague statement about “disease,” a refusal to confirm numbers, an attempt to move bodies into a hospital mortuary without notifying its management, bodies left on the floor because there was nowhere else to put them. This is not the conduct of an institution confident in its own innocence. It is the conduct of an institution that knows exactly what it did and hoped the public would not ask too many questions. The narrative the government initially pushed does not tally with the reality on ground, and Nigerians should not pretend otherwise simply because a panel has since been inaugurated and officers paraded before cameras. Accountability theatre is not accountability.

We say plainly what many Nigerians already know from lived experience: too many security personnel in this country across too many agencies do not regard the ordinary Nigerian as a citizen with rights, but as a subject to be processed, extorted, or discarded. The alleged demand for a N500,000 bail payment from a grieving father whose son was already dead is not an isolated failure of one bad commandant in one command. It is a symptom of a culture in which uniform and authority are treated as licence rather than responsibility. Until that culture is confronted honestly (not just in Minna, but across the Nigeria Police Force, the NSCDC, and every agency that holds citizens in custody) Minna will not be the last mass death in a Nigerian cell.

We therefore call on the heads of every security agency in this country, not only the NSCDC, to personally inspect the detention facilities under their command without notice and without ceremony and to certify publicly whether those facilities meet basic standards of ventilation, capacity, water access, and medical care. If they cannot make that certification honestly today, they must explain to Nigerians why not, and what they intend to do about it before another cell becomes another morgue.

The independent committee inaugurated by the Minister of Interior must be allowed to work without interference, and its findings (including the identities of those responsible and the chain of command that permitted this) must be published in full. Suspension is not justice. Detention pending investigation is not justice. Only prosecution, restitution to the families, and structural reform of how this country treats the people in its custody will begin to answer for what happened in Minna. Thirty-seven Nigerians went into state custody alive. Anything short of full accountability for how 37 Nigerians came out dead is a second betrayal, layered on top of the first.

Join Daily Trust WhatsApp Community For Quick Access To News and Happenings Around You.