Top Producers Don’t Move For Money; They Move For Belief

This voice experience is generated by AI. Learn more.This voice experience is generated by AI. Learn more.JJ Mazzo is the Executive Vice President at CrossCountry Mortgage, IMPACT Business Coach Founder, and Author.

gettyEvery recruiting conversation in our industry seems to start in the same place: the compensation package. What is the split? What is the signing bonus? What does the pricing look like?

Those questions matter. Nobody should pretend they do not. But after years of building a team and sitting across the table from some of the best producers in the business, I have learned something most recruiting strategies miss.

Money gets you the meeting. It rarely gets you the move. And it almost never keeps someone for the long haul.​

High performers who switch teams only for money will leave for money. The ones who stay, grow and help build something lasting are looking for something deeper. They want to believe in where they are going and who they are going with.

Here is what that looks like in practice.

Top producers are not joining a company. They are joining a person. They want to know who will challenge them, who will have their back on a hard day and who will still be around five years from now.

That means leaders have to show up to recruiting conversations as themselves. Share your vision. Share your standards. Share where you have failed and what you learned. A polished pitch is forgettable. A real leader with a clear direction is not.

Before any recruiting conversation, ask yourself one question: Would I follow me?

The best producers are rarely unhappy with what they earn. They are frustrated with how much further they could go. They have hit a ceiling, and they are looking for someone who can help them break through it.

So talk about growth, not just compensation. What coaching will they get? What systems will give them time back? What does their business look like in three years if they plug into your platform and your people?

If you cannot answer those questions clearly, the conversation will drift back to the numbers every time. And the numbers are the easiest thing for a competitor to match.

I saw this firsthand with a team in the Southeast producing several hundred million dollars a year. They were not shopping for a bigger split. They were tired of watching good deals stall and fall apart before closing, and they wanted to build something bigger than their own production: a region they could lead.

So we never opened with compensation. Before we sat down, we studied their market, identified the builder relationships still open to them and built a 24-month plan showing how their team could grow into a multi-branch operation. The conversation was about the business they wanted to own three years from now, not the offer on the table that day.

They recently joined our division. The plan we built to earn their trust is now the plan we are executing together. That is the difference between recruiting someone and partnering with them.

Culture cannot be described in a slide deck. It has to be experienced.

Invite candidates into real moments. A team meeting. A recognition event. A training session where your people are sharpening each other. Let them talk to your producers without you in the room. What they hear from peers will be more convincing than anything you say.

If you are nervous about what they might hear, that is not a recruiting problem. That is a culture problem, and it deserves your attention first.

Some of the best hires take years. A producer who is not ready today may be ready next year, or the year after. The leaders who win are the ones who keep showing up in the meantime without pressure and without an agenda.

Check in. Send a note when they have a big month. Invite them to an event. Offer help even when they are not on your team. Generosity builds trust, and trust is what someone remembers when they finally decide it is time to make a change.

Recruiting is not a campaign. It is a relationship.

Nothing damages a recruiting strategy faster than bringing in someone who does not share your values. One wrong hire, especially a high-profile one, can signal to your entire team that production matters more than character.

Be willing to walk away. Set a clear standard for who fits and hold it, even when the numbers are tempting. The people already on your team are watching how you recruit, and they will judge your culture by who you let in.

Compensation will always be part of the conversation. Every serious competitor can offer a strong package. Very few can offer a leader worth following, a clear path to grow and a culture people are proud to be part of.

That is the advantage worth building. When you get it right, you stop chasing top producers. They start calling you.

Money moves people for a season. Belief moves them for a career.​

Forbes Coaches Council is an invitation-only community for leading business and career coaches. Do I qualify?