Lindsay Clancy’s lawyer speaks out after retrial date set
Published: 11:39 EST, 17 November 2026 | Updated: 11:39 EST, 17 November 2026
Her ex-husband, family members, friends and colleagues all spoke about her being a loving mother and doting nurse.
Several psychiatrists and medical professionals shared details of her innermost thoughts and mental health struggles.
And even a handful of jurors waived their anonymity to lend their voices to the criminal trial that commanded the national spotlight earlier this year.
Yet Lindsay Clancy, the woman at the heart of the tragedy, has remained silent.
But now, as she heads into round two of her trial for killing her three children in the throes of a postpartum mental health battle, is there a possibility that could change?
In an exclusive interview with the Daily Mail, Clancy’s defense attorney Kevin Reddington would not rule out the possibility that the mom-of-three could take the stand during her second trial.
‘That’s one of those issues that you have to wait to find out,’ he said with a smile.
The 36-year-old former labor and delivery nurse is still struggling, both mentally and with the knowledge that she killed her children, five-year-old Cora, three-year-old Dawson and eight-month-old Callan that awful day in 2023.
She remains on suicide watch inside Massachusetts’s Tewksbury Hospital and continues to receive round-the-clock care.
But Reddington believes that, now that a retrial is set in stone, she will be able to get through it.
‘She’s a very strong person. She has a very strong faith. She knows that she’s supported by many, many people – family, friends and innumerable people,’ he said.
‘She knows that she was caught in the vortex of this whirlwind of horrific medical care and horrible medication, and knows that at least this case has been and will be able to put a light on the treatment of women with mental health issues.’
Reddington spoke to the Daily Mail outside Plymouth County Superior Court, Massachusetts, on Monday, moments after the prosecution finally revealed their intentions to retry Clancy on first-degree murder charges and a second trial date was set.
The veteran defense attorney, who prior to Clancy’s case was best known for representing mobster James Whitey Bulger’s girlfriend Catherine Greig, responded to the prosecution’s decision to bring the highest possible charges and shared his thoughts on the possibility of a plea deal.
He also revealed the impact the case has taken on his own life and the challenges of seating a jury in the high-profile case – particularly after the fallout from the holdout juror, whose conduct remains shrouded in mystery.
During Monday’s pivotal hearing, Judge William Sullivan set a date of March 29, 2027, for Clancy’s retrial, despite the prosecution’s efforts to delay it until later that year – a timeline that could have surpassed the judge’s mandatory retirement and resulted in further delays.
Prosecutors Jennifer Sprague and Shanan Buckingham also indirectly confirmed they are again seeking first-degree murder charges.
Plymouth County District Attorney Tim Cruz’s office initially brought first-degree murder charges mere days after Clancy strangled her children and tried to kill herself inside their Duxbury home on January 24, 2023.
At her first trial, Clancy pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity, arguing she was not criminally responsible because she was suffering from postpartum psychosis and depression.
Eleven jurors believed Clancy was not criminally responsible while a lone holdout, Michael Desronvil, believed she should be convicted of murder. With the jury deadlocked, a mistrial was declared and prosecutors were left to decide whether to retry her and on what charges.
Sprague skirted the judge’s question about the charges on Monday, but said that the retrial will require a jury. It was a comment that indirectly proved their intentions because, under state law, Clancy could opt for a bench trial if faced with lesser charges.
Clancy’s defense only learned the prosecution’s decision at that moment.
Reddington said he was ‘not surprised’: ‘I never expected anything less from Mr Cruz.’
But he is ‘disappointed’ – not just for Clancy but for the many others now faced with reliving the children’s deaths inside a courtroom all over again.
‘I’m not surprised. I had pretty much predicted that all along,’ he said.
‘But I am very disappointed. I feel badly for Lindsay, for her family, for everybody that this case has touched and will continue to touch including the court staff, police, first responders, everybody. It’s just terrible. Patrick [Clancy too], it goes on and on. Jurors that we don’t even know who they are yet who will be sitting here in the spring for five weeks. Terrible.’
It is not clear if the DA consulted Patrick, Clancy’s now ex-husband and the children’s father, before reaching its decision.
Patrick only attended the first trial on the two days when the state summoned him to testify.
In a statement when the mistrial was declared, Patrick’s attorney said ‘the prospect of reliving this tragedy through another trial is extraordinarily painful.’
In the three years since the killings, he has taken steps to rebuild his life, moving to New York and remarrying. He and his new wife, fertility specialist Dr Rachel Danis, are expecting their first child.
Now, he could be summoned to testify again about the deaths of his three eldest children around the same time he welcomes his fourth.
The Daily Mail has contacted the DA’s office for comment.
As well as the toll of a retrial on the victims, Reddington believes that seating a jury a second time in the high-profile case will prove challenging.
‘It’s a very emotional case. Nobody is more aware of the loss of these three children than Lindsay and her family and people close to them.
‘It’s a terrible, terrible case. People are entitled to their opinion, obviously. But I think we could try to pick a jury in Spain and have difficulty.’
The first trial sensationally ended with accusations that the holdout juror refused to follow the law around reasonable doubt. It also emerged post-trial that Desronvil had a prior domestic violence arrest, spurring questions about his truthfulness during jury selection.
Desronvil’s attorney Heather O’Connor told the Daily Mail last week that he had no doubts about Clancy’s guilt and answered the forms truthfully.
Based on the allegations, Reddington sought an investigation into Desronvil and moved to dismiss the charges on double jeopardy grounds, arguing a mistrial was avoidable.
Judge Sullivan denied both motions last week, paving the way for the retrial.
Clancy’s attorneys are appealing the motion to dismiss.
But the legal avenues involving the holdout appear to be over.
‘I don’t even call him the holdout juror. I call him the obstructionist juror,’ Reddington said of Desronvil.
‘His shelf life is expired. And, as Ronald Reagan said, we’ll consign him to the dustbin of history.’
A bench trial could have alleviated any concerns around selecting jurors this time around. It would also likely have led to a significantly shorter trial than the seven weeks seen in the first.
Reddington said he and Clancy had not decided if that was the route they would take if lesser charges had been brought.
‘That depends on a lot of factors, not the least of which is I’d have to speak at length with her and find out what her position would be on it, and then would evaluate it and see who the judge is and that type of thing,’ he said.
As it stands, he insists he would not do anything differently with his defense case a second time around.
The only possibility could be some different witnesses, he said.
One thing he is certain of is that there is no chance of a plea deal being reached before trial.
When asked if there was anything the DA’s office could offer that could be considered, he said: ‘I wouldn’t bet against myself. If they want to come and talk to me, then they know where I am.’
The overwhelming attention on the case has also impacted Reddington who went from being a high-profile Massachusetts attorney to a national household name overnight.
Social media users described him as a feminist folk hero while supporters turned up wearing merchandise adorned with his photo and courtroom phrases.
But backlash also followed and in the final days of the trial, Reddington turned up to court with a private security guard.
‘You’d have to ask my wife that question to be honest with you,’ Reddington laughed when asked how the case had impacted his life. ‘It’s been very emotional and draining for a lot of people, including myself.’
He admitted that he has received threats but brushes off concerns. ‘That comes with the terrain. So it’s not something to get stressed about.’
Instead, Reddington is focused on Clancy and getting her through a second trial.
‘She is a very kind, decent person who was a wonderful mother, wonderful wife, great nurse. People were lined up from here to Boston to testify for her and her character,’ he said.
‘There’s not a person in that courtroom or in this county or in this state, that would have anything bad to say about her other than the prosecution.’
Reported by dailymail.co.uk.
Read Original Report at dailymail.co.uk ↗
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share your opinion!