The Ute Indian Tribe says it was running a hunting checkpoint on its land. Then county deputies showed up.

The Ute Indian Tribe says it was running a hunting checkpoint on its land. Then county deputies showed up.

(Francisco Kjolseth | The Salt Lake Tribune) Ute Indian Tribe Chairman Shaun Chapoose speaks during the 15th Annual Governor’s Native American Summit held on the Utah Valley University campus on Friday, Aug. 6, 2021.

Deep in the center of the Uinta Basin desert, officers from the Ute Indian Tribe of Utah set up a hunting checkpoint last month at the same spot they have for the last several decades.

Near the intersection of two winding rural roads, they prepared to stop anyone coming into the well-known corridor for wild game — including some of the biggest trophy bucks in the state — to make sure they could properly hunt there.

Only officially enrolled Utes are allowed to hunt on tribal property. That’s been the case since January 2024, when tribal leaders banned nonmembers after they said nonmembers were leaving behind trash and riding ATVs, which are strictly prohibited on Ute land.

But that run-of-the-mill checkpoint early Oct. 16 was soon met with confrontation. Now, it’s the center of a debate over tribal rights, including allegations of unlawful interference and accusations of discrimination and intimidation against Native Americans.

Shortly after tribal officers stopped and turned around a few individuals, deputies from the Uintah County Sheriff’s Office showed up that morning — and brought an FBI agent with them.

Both the tribe and the sheriff’s office have each put out statements about what they say happened next.

The sheriff’s office alleges the checkpoint was “unlawful.” That’s because, according to its statement, it fell on a road that belongs to Uintah County. The Ute Tribe did not have authority to set up the checkpoint there and didn’t follow Utah law in getting authorization for it, the sheriff’s office asserts.

So deputies shut it down, according to the statement — and officials advised anyone stopped by the tribe to reach out to the law enforcement agency.

The sheriff’s office did not respond to a Salt Lake Tribune request to speak about the situation further.

The Ute Tribe, in its statement, rebuked the agency’s characterization and called the deputies’ actions “an egregious attack on tribal sovereignty.”

The tribe says it was conducting an appropriate checkpoint on its own trust lands with its fish and game officers. The tribe asserts it got an OK from tribal court and approval from the federal Bureau of Indian Affairs, which sent officers to help.

The checkpoint occurred within the boundaries of the tribe’s Uintah and Ouray Reservation, the tribe noted. It’s the second-largest Indigenous reservation in the country at 4.5 million acres.

Of that, 1.3 million acres are trust lands occupied by the tribe and under its direct authority.

“We were surprised and disappointed that even when the tribe is operating a lawful hunting checkpoint that it has been doing for decades, the Uintah County sheriff would challenge that activity,” said Shaun Chapoose, the chairman of the Ute Tribe’s governing Business Committee, in a statement.

The tribe’s attorney also did not respond to a Tribune request to further discuss the situation.

“The tribe should not have to continuously fight the county to protect our sovereignty over our own lands,” Chapoose’s statement continued.

The tribe also alleged it’s not the first time the county has “taken actions that infringe on the tribe’s lands and jurisdiction.”

The tribe’s checkpoint was set up along Seep Ridge Road, near where it crosses with Turkey Track Road.

The Tribune independently reviewed several maps, including from the county, state, tribe and federal government. All point to the location sitting within the Ute Tribe’s trust land holdings.

(Christopher Cherrington | The Salt Lake Tribune)

That would put it squarely in the tribe’s purview to monitor and enforce how it sees fit, said Addie Rolnick, a law professor at the University of Nevada, Las Vegas, who specializes in tribal law and Indigenous rights.

Tribal land ownership can be complicated, Rolnick said. If, for instance, the tribe had purchased the land in a private bid, it would have rights as a landowner but not jurisdiction as a government.

But trust lands are clear-cut, she noted.

“Tribal trust land, wherever it is, the default is to the tribe,” she said.

The tribe said it stands by its rightful jurisdiction of the land. But it noted its officers disbanded the checkpoint “in order to avert the confrontation that the county sheriff deputies had started.”

The tribe asserts the law is on its side, citing court precedent. That includes precedent established through cases the Ute Tribe brought against the state and won since the 1970s, repeatedly affirming its jurisdiction.

Perhaps the most notable among those was a 10th Circuit Court of Appeals ruling in 2015, which the tribe mentioned in its statement.

The appellate court in that case sided with the Ute Tribe and scolded Uintah County prosecutors for going after Ute tribal members who allegedly committed crimes on tribal land ­— a place where the court said county prosecutors had no jurisdiction.

In that ruling, then-appellate Judge Neil Gorsuch — now a U.S. Supreme Court justice — noted that if “the defendants persist in failing to respect” precedent, “they may expect to meet with sanctions in the district court or in this one.”

The road in question — Seep Ridge Road — has been hotly disputed since at least the 1980s. At that time, it was a two-way gravel road.

Uintah County’s government had long wanted to pave the 46 miles within its borders that leads to the popular Book Cliffs hunting and fishing area.

Environmentalists were strongly opposed. But it was eventually completed in 2014 with state and county funding.

It continues to be a source of contention. The pavement from Uintah County’s construction ends at the county line. Neighboring Grand County officials have so far declined to pick up and pave the final stretch to the Book Cliffs, completing the so-called Book Cliffs Highway, over concerns for wildlife, as well as the potential risks of oil and gas transportation. The project is currently suspended.

(Rick Egan | The Salt Lake Tribune) Deer roam in the Willow Creek area of Utah's Book Cliffs.

Now, the road is at the center of the checkpoint dispute.

And Rolnick, the Nevada law professor, says court precedent favors the tribe.

While the road may have been paved and paid for by the county — and owned by the county — if it runs through tribal land, it is ultimately under tribal control.

She noted a recent U.S. Supreme Court ruling that found tribal officers had the right to pull over anyone driving through tribal land suspected of committing a crime.

That explicitly included, she said, on a right of way not owned by a tribe that passes through a reservation.

In Nevada, for instance, Rolnick said “there are a lot of cases where tribes are located right on highways.”

“And they maintain that jurisdiction there,” she said.

There is some legal debate about whether tribal courts and tribal law have authority over nonmembers, she added. But laws around hunting and fishing are “among that where power is pretty strongly recognized” for tribes, she said.

With the checkpoint, she said, “this seems like an instance in which tribal law enforcement is conducting limited checks on crimes.”

In its statement, the tribe said it has “the express and clear right to exercise its jurisdiction over reservation roadways,” asserting it’s not required to obtain state permission to exercise that right.

“Any such requirement would fly in the face of centuries of treaties between the tribe and the United States, as well as the fundamental principles of tribal sovereignty,” the statement continued.

The debate over Seep Ridge Road follows recent tribal land-sale disputes with the state.

The Ute Tribe had planned to bid on Book Cliffs land — at the end of the planned highway — which the state’s Trust Lands Administration listed for sale this year.

But state lawmakers in 2024 changed Utah law to allow the Trust Lands Administration to sell land to state agencies first. The Utah Division of Wildlife Resources ultimately bought the land for $30 million.

That law change came after the tribe had also bid on and alleges it was kept from being allowed to buy its ancestral homelands at Tabby Mountain. It has an ongoing lawsuit against the state over that.

sltrib.com is now free to access — no subscription required. We made this decision because we believe access to trustworthy, independent news shouldn’t depend on what you can afford — especially as misinformation and AI-generated content continue to rise.

Free to read doesn’t mean free to produce. Our reporters show up every day to ask hard questions and hold powerful institutions to account. That work takes resources. As a nonprofit newsroom, we rely on support from people who believe it matters. Make a donation today to fund local news that serves Utah communities.

You can help us bring more local news to more communities today.

Sponsored: Salt Lake City offers everything you’d want in a holiday vacation.

📰 Original Source Attribution

Reported by sltrib.com.

Read Original Report at sltrib.com ↗
Share: WhatsApp WhatsApp
💬

Comments (0)

Join the Conversation

No comments yet. Be the first to share your opinion!

You may like