Namibia: Wal-Mart Will Crush Small Businesses

    0
    37


    The Namibian (Windhoek)

    Jo-MarÉ Duddy

    13 December 2011


    IF Wal-Mart is allowed to enter the Namibian market unconditionally, it will crush small retailers, and with them, the country’s efforts to diversify its economy and create jobs.

    Businesspeople and experts were united in this message at yesterday’s public hearing on the proposed merger between US giant Wal-Mart and Massmart. The public hearing followed after the Supreme Court ruled last month that Trade and Industry Minister Hage Geingob had to review the conditions set by the Namibian Competition Commission (NaCC) for the merger. The NaCC wants local participation in the deal, and requires that the merger won’t result in any job losses or cause unfair competition.

    About 90 per cent of all retailers in Namibia are in the small and medium enterprise (SME) sector, James Hodge, a South African economist specialising in competition matters, told the hearing yesterday.

    Acting on behalf of the NaCC, Hodge said these small retailers employ about 74 per cent of all workers in the retail sector. And of this 74 per cent, about 70 per cent are historically disadvantaged Namibians, he said.

    “Wal-Mart isn’t just any other retailer,” Hodge told Geingob, who was flanked by his Deputy Tjekero Tweya and Permanent Secretary Malan Lindeque.

    “Wal-Mart is 40 times the size of the entire Namibian economy,” Hodge said.

    Its buying power is in the vicinity of US$408 billion, which means it can negotiate the cheapest prices around the globe.

    Not only will retail suffer, Namibia’s budding manufacturing sector will also be dealt a blow, Hodge said.

    Referring to local manufacturers like Namibia Dairies and Namib Mills, he said Namibia has made “some traction” in manufacturing, but that this will come under pressure once Wal-Mart gets a foot in the door.

    Wal-Mart may integrate local manufacturers and introduce them to other markets, but this needs to be ensured, Hodge said.

    Another concern is Wal-Mart’s “unique reputation” when it comes to labour practices, he said. The company is known for low wages, few benefits and an anti-union stance.

    Tarah Shaanika, chief executive officer of the Namibia Chamber of Commerce and Industry (NCCI), echoed the NaCC’s sentiments.

    “When someone very strong gets into a boxing ring against someone very weak, there needs to be some rules,” Shaanika said.

    “We’re not saying that Wal-Mart will twist arms, but it has the potential to do so,” he said.

    Heiko Niedermeyer, managing director of Neo Paints, also called on Geingob to put some measures in place to level the playing field.

    He said retailers that are currently “sympathetic” to local manufacturers are Namibian retailers. Unless Wal-Mart is subjected to conditions, these retailers will be pushed out as they won’t be able to compete, Niedermeyer said.

    AllAfrica – All the Time

    More News on allAfrica.com