Ghana’s Biometric Registration: Some Troubling Questions

    0
    68


    Biometric Voting

    The decision to introduce a system of biometric registration as
    a prelude to implementing biometric voting in future elections in
    Ghana, is laudable and welcomed by all the political parties.
    However, intentions apart, the type of equipment chosen, its
    overall capabilities, and the manner of introducing the system is
    as important as the idea itself. To that end, this article seeks to
    pose searching questions with the view to agitating the awareness
    of stakeholders and the nation at large, and act as a prompt to the
    governing authorities not to take anything for granted in this
    important endeavor.

    Although Ghana’s 2008 elections were cleared
    by foreign monitoring agencies as free and fair, there were
    nonetheless claims and counter claims of numerous electoral
    malpractices in particular sections of the country, notably the
    Volta and the Ashanti regions, depending on your political
    persuasion. It was therefore a timely suggestion to introduce
    biometrics into our electoral system. With this, the omens were
    good that Ghana was poised to further advance her democracy

    Tangible steps towards this realization started when an advert
    appeared in the UKTI (United Kingdom Trade Institute) news
    letter, as follows:

    “Wednesday, 16 Feb
    2011

    Ghana – Biometric Technology for Voter
    Register

    Opportunity to supply and install biometric
    technology to replace existing voter register in
    Ghana.

    Tender deadline: 09/03/2011â€

    Other tangible steps in the biometric endeavor include the
    government allocating GH¢50 million initially, and
    ultimately $85million for the biometric registration exercise.

    In as much as there are these outwardly stated
    intentions to introduce a biometric system into
    Ghana’s electoral system and consequently ensure
    a fraud-free set of future elections, regrettably there are equally
    disturbing questions that need answering; issues that need
    resolving.

    Searching Questions:

    i) At the time of deciding to write this piece
    over a week ago, the Electoral Commission had not yet convened an
    IPAC meeting, as called for by the NPP and PNC to resolve budding
    issues, forestall any suspicions and mistrust of the process and
    generally reach a consensus by all stakeholders. Why this
    unwarranted delay in convening an IPAC meeting then, one may ask?
    Is there a credible connection between David
    Kanga’s role as Deputy Chairman of the Electoral
    Commission responsible for Electoral Operations and his perceived
    sympathies toward the ruling NDC?
                                 The
    IPAC finally convened, but, as predicted- the very reason why Kanga
    should have convened IPAC earlier- issues arose whereby an
    injunction has been taken out by one of the parties against the
    process. The result of all this is that the opening of the register
    is indeterminably delayed until the injunction issues and possibly
    newer ones arise, and are resolved. With 2012, not a distant future
    from now, it begs the question whether the registration exercise
    once opened, will reach the entire country before closing,
    analyzing, resolving anomalies, before implementation on Election
    Day.

    ii) How was the decision reached on the
    preferred bidder to supply the biometric equipment? Was the short
    listing process truly open and transparent without
    ‘brown envelope’, 10%
    kick-backs taking precedence over quality, coming into play? How
    else then do we hear of an injunction by aggrieved parties against
    winning bidder?

    iii) Of the types of biometric equipment
    available on the market, what informed
    government’s choice of the type chosen for
    Ghana? Indeed, was it the EC’s or the
    government’s prerogative in this choice?

    iv) Is the registration process starting from
    scratch, or is it utilizing available databases such as those held
    at the Passport, DVLA, NHIS offices? If not, why not? I would have
    thought that cost and time imperatives would have dictated the
    utilization of existing databases.

    v) Has the preferred equipment been stress
    tested elsewhere for accuracy, that is, minimizing false acceptance
    and ensuring it would be robust and fit for purpose?

    vi) Will the EC and the government confirm or deny that
    the equipment chosen does not have a verification capability which
    would essentially make a farce of the entire endeavor? This
    question is critical because the purpose of a biometric register is
    to lock out duplicity, impersonation and multiple voting potential
    for those so desirous. It cannot be overemphasized that if the
    government, in collaboration with the EC, controversially goes
    ahead with half measures, by introducing biometric equipment
    without verification capability to prevent multiple voting then, as
    the flagbearer of the NPP, Nana Akufo Addo recently stated and
    backed by the NPP Chairman, Jake Obetsebi Lamptey, the object would
    be missed and the investment money ought to be better utilized
    elsewhere! This will be the case if it were true that the preferred
    bidder’s equipment does not have a verification
    capability. What would be the point in having a biometric register
    which on Election Day cannot confirm a name on the register with
    the person presenting himself at a polling station as the named
    person to vote? Of what use is the new system then? How can the
    government justify using the country’s scarce
    foreign exchange in this wasteful manner? Hard-up Ghanaians deserve
    better!

    vii) The Ashanti Region is suggested as the
    sample region for the biometric registration exercise. What
    informed the decision of the EC/government in making this
    choice?  This decision smacks of political expediency
    on the one hand, and flies in the face of sampling logic on the
    other. First of all, with the political expediency, it is as clear
    as daylight that an NDC administration choosing an NPP stronghold
    as a sample area needs no genius to decipher why. As with the
    fiasco of the 2010 population census, there also was the 2000
    National Photo Identification exercise which also had the Ashanti
    region as the sample area. Guess what? The exercise ended with the
    Ashanti Region, meaning that whereas voters in that region voted
    with IDs, the Volta region, for example, voted without photo
    identification. If this is anything to go by, one could be excused
    in being skeptical that the Ashanti Region has again been chosen by
    another NDC administration as a sample area for the biometric
    registration exercise. Considering the intended merits of
    biometrics – to prevent fraudulent voting
    practices – if the stronghold of the NDC, the
    Volta Region, is not covered by the registration before time runs
    out for the 2012 elections, effectively, the administration would
    be open to justified criticisms of emasculating the NPP whilst
    benefiting from possible fraudulent votes in the Volta Region. Any
    fair-minded government would be at pains to avoid this occurrence
    so as to appear honorable, and I pray our vaunted
    ‘asomdwe hene’ President
    Mills would intervene against this.

    On the issue of the sample area itself, it is illogical and for
    that matter lends credence to the previous point, to choose the
    largest region – Ashanti –
    for sampling. The Wikipedia defines a sample size
    as:
    “Sample size determination
    is the act of choosing the number of observations to include in
    a
    statistical
    sample
    . The sample size is an important feature of any
    empirical study in which the goal is to make
    inferences
    about a population
    from a sample. In practice, the sample size used in a study is
    determined based on the expense of data collection, and the need to
    have sufficient
    statistical
    power
    .â€

     In essence therefore, other than for the
    political reason aforementioned, cost and time imperatives dictate
    that a smaller (Upper West) to medium size (Volta) region ought to
    be considered rather than the largest region. This would ensure a
    speedier completion and quicker examination of the sample results
    prior to wider implementation. The thrust of my argument is that
    for both political transparency, as well as time and cost
    implications, the Ashanti region ought not to be the sample region
    for the biometric registration.

    Could the government, the EC, IEA, and IPAC please heed the call
    to ensure this foray into the next level of our democratic
    development, is cost effective, transparent, universally acceptable
    and ultimately worthwhile. I stress that the country goes for the
    full biometric package, or else leave the status quo alone. An
    idiom is apt here: ‘A thing worth doing is worth
    doing well’, and the epicurean view also comes
    to mind: ‘Drink deep or taste not the Pierian
    spring; half a knowledge is a dangerous thing’!
    I also call upon these same bodies and agencies to seriously
    consider the questions and suggestions raised by the think tank
    group IMANI on the issue of the infrastructure, test regime and
    other security measures relating to biometrics.

    As a footnote, is there more than a hint of assured knowledge of
    underhanded maneuverings in President Mills’
    confident prediction that 2012 is a forgone conclusion, and so
    adios until 2017 when he would ‘peacefully
    handover’? Is there an implied threat that 2012
    would not witness an above board election where peace can be taken
    for granted? Well, the realist in me believes that such a confident
    prediction in the face of dire national conditions which would
    normally portend an insecure future for government, can only mean
    the resolved determination to win at all costs, fair or foul!

    My call also goes to all Ghanaians to be alert to anything that
    can result in a recurrence of a ‘stolen
    verdict’ situation as witnessed in 1996. Your
    activism or apathy, will determine whether or not you get a
    government you may or may not have consciously and freely voted
    for. A flawed biometric registration system without a verification
    potential, coupled with the EC office inhabited by a not so neutral
    2-IC, is a recipe for this outcome and must be resisted.

    Long live Ghana

    Long live our Democracy

    Richard Dombo Diedong LL.B (Hons)

    Read More:
    Ghana’s Biometric Registration: Some Troubling Questions