Business Daily (Nairobi)
Mugambi Mutegi
20 July 2011
Government operations risk being shut down as the August 27 date draws closer without the appointment of the Controller of Budget even as the current holder of the office prepares to leave.
Public finance experts say there is real danger of government agencies being denied access to money that has been allocated to them in the Budget in the absence of a Controller of Budget.
The Constitution requires the Controller of Budget to authorise all withdrawals from the Consolidated Fund — the official government account into which all tax revenues or money received from other sources is deposited. “Money shall not be withdrawn from the Consolidated Fund unless the Controller of Budget has approved the withdrawal,” the Constitution says in Article 206.
Government agencies and departments access money allocated to them by seeking the authority of the Controller of Budget to have it transferred to the Exchequer.This is the process that clears the way for ministries and government agencies to charge their votes on the Exchequer. Senior Treasury officials have warned that any vacuum in the office of the Controller of Budget could shut down a key artery through which money moves inside government bringing operations to a standstill. “Government operations could come to a halt if the Controller of Budget is not in office one year after the Constitution comes into effect,” Joseph Kinyua, the Permanent Secretary in the Ministry of Finance, told the Business Daily in an interview three months ago.
“The most important officer we need to have recruited by August 27 is the Controller of Budget because he is the holder of purse strings for government expenditure,” said the PS.
That sense of urgency, however, appears to have escaped the majority of Kenyans whose attention remains fixed on the office of the Attorney-General that falls vacant on the same date.
Concern over the risk that a vacancy in the office of the Controller of Budget poses to government operations has continued to rise in recent weeks as the deadline draws closer without any signs that the appointing authority has begun the process of finding the right candidate.
The holder of the office must be appointed according to the Independent Officers Appointment Act that President Kibaki signed into law on July 5.
The law requires the appointing authority to advertise the vacancy in the Kenya Gazette and notices in the media within five days of the law coming into force.
The announcement marks the beginning of the search process that includes the Public Service Commission (PSC) receiving applications from interested parties, the vetting of the candidates and the picking of three candidates whose names are forwarded to the President for nomination.The President is expected to forward a name to Parliament for approval before a formal appointment is made. “We have to wait for the appointing authority to place the advert,” said Alice Otwala, the PSC deputy secretary.
It is estimated that the entire process of hiring a public official under the new Act takes at least 45 days, but the law allows up to a maximum of 56 days.
Publication of the notice today would require the different players in the entire process to fast-track their roles to finish in the remaining 37 days.
Some experts point to the provision that allows the President, in consultation with the Prime Minister, to extend the process for a period not exceeding 21 days by a notice in the Gazette.
Such an extension would, however, only leave the office of Controller of Budget vacant and deny state agencies money from the Exchequer.
Inability to draw money from the Exchequer will render the government unable to pay civil servants as well as pay for goods and services. The office of the Budget Controller is critical to the disbursement and is accountable to Parliament.
Currently, permanent secretaries apply to the office of the Controller and Auditor General for authority to draw money from the Exchequer.
Separate
The Constitution has separated the two offices under a new framework that comes into force on August 27.
Tiberius Barasa, a public policy analyst at the Centre for Policy Research, reckons that the government could get out of the dilemma by asking the deputy auditor general to assume the duties of his former boss –a move that lawyers say would be illegal.
“With the offices being assumed non-functioning, another scenario would see the Public Accounts Committee in conjunction with Treasury step in to avert a financing crisis,” Mr Barasa said.
Justice and Constitutional Affairs minister Mutula Kilonzo has admitted that the ongoing rush in setting up constitutional offices is avoidable to prevent a looming crisis.
“The public stands to lose if constitutional offices are not set up in a timely fashion,” he said.
“The setting up of such an office should have coincided with the Finance Bill which came up for its first reading yesterday,” he said.
Matters are not made any better by the fact that Parliament has not passed the Controller of Budget Bill 2011 that should govern the office once it is set up. The Commission for the Implementation of the Constitution (CIC) website says that the Bill remains in the “internal review and stakeholder consultations” stage.
On approval by the CIC, the draft Bill will be presented to the Attorney- General for preparation and release to the Cabinet, which on approval will send it to Parliament for passing before the President signs it into law.
President Kibaki was in February forced to retract his nomination of Agriculture Development Company (ADC) chief executive William Kirwa as the controller of budget after the courts declared it unlawful.
Additional Reporting by Moses Michira
AllAfrica – All the Time
Visit site:
Crisis Looms in Failure to Appoint New Budget Chief
