Stakeholders knock Senate over ‘watered down’ FoI Bill

    0
    23

    Stakeholders in the media have criticised Freedom of Information Bill (FoI) passed by the Senate yesterday.

    Although they described the passage as a welcome development, they expressed dissatisfaction with some of its sections, especially the clause that mandates journalists to disclose their sources of information.

    President, Nigeria Union of Journalists (NUJ), Garba Muhammed condemned the “‘watered down bill”.

    Garba spoke to The Nation in a phone interview. He said the clause that mandates journalists to disclose their sources is; “uncalled for and detrimental to democracy.”

    “I think the passage of the FoI Bill is a good development as expected but it is regrettable to know that some sections have been watered down; this is not our expectation. The issue of journalists disclosing their sources is uncalled for, it should not arise, and it is an issue that puts the national security at stake.”

    Garba said the NUJ would not relent. “We are going to call a stakeholders meeting to address those sections not favourable to the media because they are not favourable to democracy. We are still waiting for the harmonisation of the bill between the House of Representatives and the Senate. We will pursue it to a logical conclusion and if they refuse to revert it, we will present it to the incoming legislature for amendment.”

    President, Nigeria Guild of Editors(NGE) Mr Gbenga Adefaye urged the joint committees of the National Assembly to ‘expunge’ the clause mandating journalists to disclose their source. Adefaye said such provision is tantamount to gagging the press.

    “The senators know it is a breach of confidence for journalists to disclose their sources.That may be done under a military regime but we are in a democracy. It is generally unacceptable. Journalists would rather go to jail than disclose their sources. We do not expect that clause to be in the law eventually. That section should be expunged,” he said.

    Abia State Governor Theodore Orji, speaking through his Special Adviser on Media, Mr Ben Onyechere, praised the National Assembly for passing the bill, but said some sections of the bill, falls below expectation. Onyechere said a situation where the media is under compulsion to disclose its sources makes journalists vulnerable to undue attack.

    “I believe journalists must be protected, because he is more or less doing a humanitarian job. A situation where he has to disclose his sources puts his life at a great risk. Although the passage of the bill is a good development, it opens them (journalists) to attack and I think such clause should be reviewed and removed. It is not good for our nascent democracy,” he said.

    Coordinator, Centre for Free Speech, Mr Richard Akinnola also expressed similar view. He said the injection of ‘foreign’ provision that mandates the media to disclose sources is unconstitutional and against the ethics of journalism.

    “On no account should any journalist declare his sources. It is a dangerous signal to the freedom of the press. It is against the universal provision in the code of ethics of journalism. It does not portend progress for journalism in Nigeria. On no account should this spurious clause arise.”

    The Director, International Press Centre (IPC), Lanre Arogundade, said the section mandating journalists to disclose their sources makes the FOI bill ‘worthless’.

    He said: “It is clearly unacceptable to the media, because it negates the ethics of journalism. It is not universally recognised. It infringes on media rights. It is more or less putting the journalist and his sources at risk. It is even a dangerous signal to the freedom of the press because it creates an atmosphere of fear. People would be discouraged from disclosing information to journalists.”

    Continue reading here:
    Stakeholders knock Senate over ‘watered down’ FoI Bill