In a significant ruling that underscores the brutal realities of crime in South Africa, Jacquen ‘Boeta’ Appollis, Steveno van Rhyn, and Kelly Smith were sentenced to life imprisonment by the Western Cape High Court on Thursday for their involvement in the harrowing kidnapping of Joshlin Smith. Judge Nathan Erasmus presided over the case and delivered a clear message: there is no room for leniency in the face of such serious crimes.
During the sentencing, Judge Erasmus highlighted that he could find no mitigating factors to justify a lesser sentence for the trio, who had shown a complete lack of remorse throughout the trial. “Ms Smith, we know from February 19, 2024, there has been a lack of concern.
But, besides some tears yesterday, you have not shown an indication of remorse,” Erasmus remarked. He further asserted that a sentence of imprisonment was the only appropriate response to their transgressions.
The judge acknowledged that substances had influenced the defendants during the commission of their crimes.
However, he decisively ruled that this could not serve as an excuse for their brutal actions. “You had enough time to speak and come clean,” he stated firmly, emphasising the premeditation involved in their actions.
A major aspect of the prosecution’s case involved a request to add the names of the three criminals to the National Child Protection Register (CPR).
This crucial register, maintained by the Western Cape Government in accordance with the Children’s Act 38 of 2005, aims to protect children from abuse and neglect. Part A records reported cases, while Part B lists individuals deemed unsuitable to work with minors. Judge Erasmus obliged, reinforcing the importance of safeguarding the vulnerable.
@iolnews This video, presented in court as part of Natasha Andrews’ statement—the woman who sought to adopt Joshlin—had the entire court in tears. #joshlinsmith #fyp #southafrica ♬ original sound – NEWS
For their roles in the kidnapping, each perpetrator received a concurrent 10-year sentence. However, given the severity of their actions, which included human trafficking, they will serve life behind bars—an outcome that advocates hope will serve as a deterrent against similar crimes.
The case has sparked widespread discussions on the pressing issue of human trafficking and child safety in South Africa. As communities reflect on this harrowing event, many seek justice and solutions to prevent future occurrences.
The sentences are to run concurrently.
