Woman Finds ‘Creepy’ VHS Tape in a Cabinet at Her 1792 Colonial Home. Then the Unexpected Happens (Exclusive)

Sarah Elaine recalled to PEOPLE how the tape was first discovered in her historic property — and whether she ever planned on watching itNEED TO KNOWContent creator Sarah Elaine found a “creepy” VHS tape alongside old photos and an inhaler in her historic Maine home’s butler’s pantry