Supermarket Christmas pudding officially crowned better than M&S — and it’s £5 cheaper
The best supermarket own-brand Christmas pudding has been revealed (Picture: Shutterstock / Anna_Pustynnikova) There are decadent desserts galore available at this time of year – from trifles and pavlovas to Yule logs, tarts, and profiteroles.
But no festive feast is complete without a Christmas pudding, the traditional treat for December 25.
Every supermarket has its own version, so working out which one to buy can be a bit of a challenge.
You might be tempted to go for Marks & Spencer, given how popular the retailer has become, but according to the results of a new taste test by Which?, there are better options out there.
The consumer champions amassed a panel of 70 Christmas pudding lovers to compare luxury puds from Aldi, Sainsbury’s, Tesco, Asda, M&S, Waitrose, and more.
For 2026, there are three puddings that you should consider, all of which were awarded ‘best buy’ accolades.
Desserts from Asda, Tesco, and Waitrose topped the rankings in the test, each scoring 75 per cent overall.
Asda Exceptional 12-Month Matured Luxury Christmas Pudding (£9 for 800g) is said to have been crafted by the world’s oldest Christmas pudding makers (Matthew Walker Puddings) and features vine fruits, glacé cherries, almonds, pecans, and walnuts.
The sponge is infused with French cognac and Spanish sherry, and the panel deemed it an ‘indulgent’ dessert, absolutely ‘packed’ with fruit and nuts.
Asda’s pudding impressed across the board, being ‘highly’ rated for its sweet taste and ‘moist texture’.
Its alcohol and spice flavour were said to be ‘relatively mild’, although this didn’t cause any issue for the vast majority of people. If you prefer a stronger taste, though, this might not be the one for you.
Next was the No.1 12-Month-Matured Christmas Pudding from Waitrose (£14 for 800g), which is quite a bit more expensive than the other two best buys, but the ‘good-looking’ dessert was deemed a worthy choice for a festive finale.
The panel ‘relished its moist texture and indulgent sweetness’ and were pleased to find there was no skimping on the ‘succulent’ fruit, with plenty of raisins, currants, and cherries, as well as pecans and walnuts inside.
Roughly two-thirds of the tasters felt the Waitrose pud had a ‘perfect’ spicy kick, while most thought the alcoholic punchiness was ‘about right’.
A few did note they’d like a ‘stronger flavour,’ but all round, there were minimal complaints.
And rounding out the three-way tie, Tesco’s Finest 12-Month Matured Christmas Pudding (£9 for 800g, although currently on Clubcard Price for £7) also proved popular with the tasters, who thought it ‘looked great’, and enjoyed that it was packed with plenty of raisins, currants, glacé cherries, pecans, and almonds.
The pud scored well for its moistness and sweet flavour, although it wasn’t rated as highly as Asda or Waitrose for its texture, being deemed ‘not quite as succulent’.
Which? adds: ‘This pudding is laced with brandy, cider, Amontillado sherry and cognac, which went down a treat with most of our tasters. However, some said they would’ve preferred a stronger alcohol and spice flavour.’
Morrisons The Best 18-Month Matured Luxury Christmas Pudding (£9 for 800g) was next up, with a score of 71 per cent.
This one contains brandy-soaked cherries and ‘generous’ amounts of pecans, walnuts, and almonds.
The majority of tasters loved the ‘moist texture’ of the pudding, and more than half said the levels of sweetness and spiciness were ‘just right’.
It also packed a real punch alcohol-wise, which half of the group loved, but others thought it was ‘a bit too much’.
Then came Sainsbury’s Taste The Difference 18-Month Matured Christmas Pudding (£9.50 for 800g), which also scored 71 per cent, and was deemed a ‘decent choice’ as it ‘looked and smelled good’.
This was another moist pud, with ‘festive spiciness’ that two-thirds of people enjoyed and a good ‘sweetness’ to it.
It only missed out on a higher score due to the strength of the alcohol, with nearly a third claiming it ‘wasn’t boozy enough’.
Lidl and M&S both earned overall scores of 70 per cent for the Lidl Deluxe 18-Month Matured Christmas Pudding (£4.49 for 400g), and the M&S Collection 12-Month Matured Christmas Pudding (£14 for 907g).
Lidl’s was said to have ‘excellent fruit and nut content,’ and the panel generally enjoyed the texture and sweetness, but many thought it lacked alcohol and spice.
Meanwhile, M&S’s one ‘looked lovely’ and had a ‘good aroma and moist texture’, but its ‘sweet spiciness’ didn’t win universal praise from the panel.
Next came Aldi’s Specially Selected 24 Month Matured Christmas Pudding (£6.99 for 800g), which scored 69 per cent. It was found to be ‘reasonably well liked’, but consumers were divided over the fruit and nut content.
And finally, Co-op’s Irresistible 12-Month Matured Christmas Pudding (£4.25 for 400g) and Iceland’s Luxury 18-Month Matured Christmas Pudding (£4 for 400g) were at the lower end of the rankings, scoring 68 per cent and 64 per cent respectively.
Co-op’s pud was mildly spiced and scored well on looks and aroma, with a ‘reasonable’ texture, but it ‘struggled to deliver on flavour’, while Iceland’s cheap pud achieved some approval for sweetness, spiciness, and texture, but it failed to wow across the board.
Which? has been carrying out a number of taste tests for the festive season, and the consumer champions have shared some of the other best buys and big winners.
Those who love to cosy up with a cup of cocoa should opt for Hotel Chocolat Classic 70 per cent Hot Chocolate Flakes (£9.95 for 280g), according to a panel of hot chocolate lovers.
The branded drink was deemed better than hot chocolate from Knoops and M&S, with a ‘luxurious’ taste, balancing sweet and bitter, with a great mouthfeel.
For smoked salmon, shoppers should head to Asda this year.
The Asda Exceptional Mild & Delicate Scottish Smoked Salmon (£4.74 for 100g) topped the test, being deemed a ‘fantastic pick for festive entertaining for less than a fiver’.
Tasters loved its ‘well-balanced’ flavour and ‘satisfying’ texture, and thought the thickness of slices was ‘spot on’.
The own-brand item beat out competition from Mowi Smoked Salmon Slices (£6 for 100g).
For those looking for a glass of Champagne to toast the holiday season, it’s Tesco that was the top scorer.
Tesco Finest Premier Cru Brut Champagne (£26 for 75cl) took the top spot, being hailed a ‘brilliant, well-balanced bubbly’.
The drink has been crowned a best buy by Which? for three years running and is a ‘benchmark champagne’.
It’s got a fresh and citrusy flavour, with apple fruit and a refined nutty finish.
The Tesco plonk beat out Veuve Clicquot Yellow Label Brut Champagne, which costs £50 for 75cl.
All of the Christmas puddings were blind-tasted and rated by a panel of 70 people.
This was a group of shoppers who enjoy Christmas pudding and who broadly represent the demographic profile of adults in the UK (age range, gender split, and more).
The puddings were tested in a fully rotated order to avoid any bias, and each tester had a private tasting booth so they couldn’t share their thoughts or be influenced by others.
The best Black Friday beauty deals on the Dr Barbara Sturm face cream and hyaluronic serum
The best Black Friday sleep deals to upgrade your bedroom with Simba’s 33% off sale
Why shoppers are rushing to snap up this 99p Audible deal before Christmas
14,500 five-star reviews later, this cult sleep spray is discounted for Black Friday
Shoppers ditch expensive dental work for these £19.99 MySweetSmile whitening strips
Each person was served 50g of each pudding, heated according to the packaging instructions. The overall score was based on 50 per cent flavour, 20 per cent appearance, 15 per cent texture, and 15 per cent aroma.
Do you have a story you’d like to share? Get in touch by emailing MetroLifestyleTeam@metro.co.uk
Arrow MORE: I legally changed my name to James Blunt just so I could find out his favourite cheese
Arrow MORE: The truth about British salmon as ads warn of ‘toxic chemicals’
Arrow MORE: New Asda boss announces major change amid checkout ‘bedlam’
Your free newsletter guide to the best London has on offer, from drinks deals to restaurant reviews.
Enter your postcode so we can deliver content close to you Close
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share your opinion!