Court of Appeal Reduces Man’s Sentence From The Death Sentence to 25 Years for Killing Brother With Forked Jembe
Sign InCourtCourt of Appeal Reduces Man's Sentence From The Death Sentence to 25 Years for Killing Brother With Forked JembeBy Andrew Kariuki · November 16, 2026 · 2 min readSponsored AdThe Court of Appeal has upheld the murder conviction of a man who fatally assaulted his younger brother with a forked jembe and a spade in Timau, Meru County, but replaced his death sentence with 25 years in prison.
In a judgment delivered on November 13, 2026, a three-judge bench comprising Justices Wanjiru Karanja, Ole Kantai and Ali-Aroni dismissed Muthiora Thuranira’s appeal against conviction but allowed his challenge to the sentence.
The court found that the prosecution had proved beyond reasonable doubt that Thuranira murdered his brother, Kai Thuranira, following an attack on the night of March 29, 2010.
Evidence presented during the trial showed that Thuranira arrived home drunk at around 8pm and questioned his younger brother about why he was still awake.
The deceased reportedly stepped outside, with Thuranira following him. Their aunt, Jane Kabiti M’mboroti, testified that she later heard the deceased screaming before seeing Thuranira assaulting him with a forked hoe and a spade.
Another eyewitness, Mary Kananu, told the court that she saw Thuranira strike his brother on the head with the forked hoe and continue beating him with the spade after he fell.
Both witnesses said they were able to see the incident because of the full moon and light from a lantern inside the house.
The deceased was rushed to hospital with serious head injuries and later transferred to the intensive care unit at Nyeri Provincial Hospital, where he remained for several weeks before dying.
A post-mortem examination established that he suffered a depressed skull fracture, traumatic brain injury and intracranial bleeding. The pathologist attributed his death to the severe penetrating head injury.
During his defence, Thuranira denied committing the offence, claiming he had been asleep when the incident occurred. He also alleged a longstanding land dispute involving his aunt’s family and suggested that another man, Michael Thimongo, could have been responsible.
However, the appellate judges found that the eyewitness accounts were consistent and reliable. They also agreed with the trial court that the failure to call Thimongo as a witness did not weaken the prosecution’s case.
The court further held that the repeated assault, the weapons used and the targeting of the deceased’s head demonstrated an intention to cause death or grievous harm, establishing malice aforethought.
Thuranira had been sentenced to death by the High Court in Meru on October 23, 2015.
However, the Court of Appeal noted that the sentence was imposed before the Supreme Court’s landmark decision in the Muruatetu case, which declared the mandatory nature of the death penalty unconstitutional.
While maintaining that the death penalty remains lawful, the judges said courts have discretion to impose proportionate sentences based on the circumstances of each case.
The court consequently set aside the death sentence and substituted it with 25 years’ imprisonment, running from the date of his arraignment in court.
Reported by uzalendonews.co.ke.
Read Original Report at uzalendonews.co.ke ↗
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share your opinion!