Former Bellingham First Responders’ COVID Vaccine Mandate Case Ends as Supreme Court Declines to Hear It

Ice Water, Math Quizzes, and Shocks: The 1948 Breastfeeding Experiment That Showed Stress Can Slow Milk FlowIn 1948, researchers stressed a nursing mother with ice water, toe pulling, and math problems with shocks. Each time, her baby got less milk. Thanksgiving 2026 Almanac Outlook Calls for Upper Midwest Snow and Eastern Rain as Travelers Plan AheadThe Old Farmer’s Almanac predicts snow in the Upper Midwest and rain in the East for Thanksgiving 2026. Here is how to plan travel safely and stay healthy. Cervical Cancer Screening Gaps Persist in the South and West as At-Home HPV Testing Expands for WomenA new study shows uneven cervical cancer screening across U.S. regions. Here are current Pap and HPV schedules and at-home testing options. Families with Children of Different Citizenship Status Can Check Each Child’s Eligibility for Medicaid or CHIP SeparatelyA JAMA Network Open study finds that over 1 million U.S. children live in families with mixed citizenship status. Learn how Medicaid and CHIP eligibility is decided for each child. Mental Health Ketamine During or After C-Sections Was Linked to Lower Early Postpartum Depression Scores Across Six TrialsSix trials linked ketamine during or after C-sections to lower early postpartum depression screening scores. The data are early and short-term. Women with Autoimmune Diseases Were Nearly 50% More Likely Than Men to Report Being Given a Psychiatric MisdiagnosisWomen with autoimmune diseases were nearly 50% more likely than men to report a psychiatric misdiagnosis in a 6,607-person survey. What to know. National Depression Screening Advice Was Linked to More Therapy and Less Antidepressant-Only Use Among Distressed AdultsAfter depression screening became routine advice, distressed adults used more therapy and fewer antidepressants alone. What patients can ask. After Bend Elementary School Shooting, Oregon Officials Urge Families to Watch Children for Signs of Trauma and GriefAfter the Bend school shooting, Oregon officials urge families to check in with kids. Trauma signs by age and where to find help. Innovation Lenire Tinnitus Device Joins U.S. ENT Guidelines as an Option Doctors May Offer for Bothersome RingingUpdated U.S. ENT tinnitus guidelines say doctors may offer Lenire’s bimodal neuromodulation. Here is what the evidence and cost look like. GLP-1 Users with Sleep Apnea Had About 40% Lower Acute Respiratory Failure Risk in Early CHEST DataSleep apnea patients on GLP-1 drugs had less acute respiratory failure in a nearly 2-million-patient CHEST 2026 analysis. What the data can’t show. FDA-Approved Brytly Becomes First Over-the-Counter Apraclonidine Eye Drop, Limited to Twice Daily with Contact Lens PrecautionsFDA approved Brytly, the first OTC apraclonidine drop for eye redness. Use it twice daily at most and see a doctor for eye pain or vision changes. A Vine Famous for Copying Plastic Leaves Showed No Mimicry in a Two-Year Greenhouse RetestA vine said to mimic plastic leaves showed no host-driven mimicry in a new preprint. Its leaves changed shape on their own, often by season. Healthy Living Middle-Aged Adults Eating the Most Ultra-Processed Food Had 40% Higher Odds of Silent Brain Damage on MRIIn 8,783 adults, the highest ultra-processed food intake was linked to 40% higher odds of silent brain damage on MRI. The study can’t prove cause. Cooley Fire Holds at 731 Acres as Smoke Triggers Bay Area Air Advisory for Sonoma, Marin, and NapaSmoke from the 731-acre Cooley Fire drifted into Sonoma, Marin, and Napa counties. What the Bay Area air advisory means and how to protect your lungs. Berkeley Springs Boil Water Advisory Now Covers Most Town Customers as Health Officials Check Affected RestaurantsMost Berkeley Springs Water Works customers remain under a boil water advisory. What it means for drinking, cooking, brushing teeth, and restaurants. Cockroach Milk Packs 3 Times the Energy of Dairy, and Its Ig Nobel Crystals Now Inspire Protein DesignCockroach milk crystals hold over 3 times the energy of dairy milk by weight. The 2016 discovery won a 2026 Ig Nobel, but it was never tested as food. Covid – 19 FDA Proposes Requiring Companies to Report Food Additives That Now Reach Grocery Shelves Without Federal ReviewFDA has released its proposed GRAS rule requiring companies to notify the agency about food additives. Here is what the proposal does and does not do. Federal Regulators Warn Some Hair Dryer Brushes Lack the Part That Stops ElectrocutionCPSC warns hair dryer brushes sold on Walmart.com and TikTok Shop lack immersion protection. The seller has not agreed to a recall or refund. A Recalled Teething Toy Broke the Pattern Parents Were Told to Look ForA newly recalled pull-string teething toy has a different model number and design from earlier recalls, and one choking incident has been reported. Trying to Lower Blood Sugar, Cholesterol or Blood Pressure? Different Workouts Suited Different MarkersA pooled analysis of 53 trials found that different exercise types helped different metabolic markers. Most of the evidence was low certainty. Mario Tama | Getty Images Share on Twitter Share on Facebook Share on Pocket The U.S. Supreme Court on Oct. 5 declined to hear a challenge by former Bellingham, Washington, first responders and city workers who lost their jobs after refusing the city’s 2021 COVID-19 vaccine requirement. The decision leaves in place rulings by two lower federal courts that dismissed their lawsuit.

The case, Brock v. City of Bellingham, appeared on the Court’s order list among petitions denied without comment. No justice noted a dissent. For the 18 former employees who brought the petition, the denial likely ends their federal case. The petition was filed Aug. 24, considered at the justices’ Sept. 28 private conference, and denied a week later.

The petitioners included former police officers, firefighters, emergency medical technicians, an inspector, and a wastewater supervisor, according to Cascadia Daily News. The original lawsuit, filed in 2024 against the city and former Mayor Seth Fleetwood, challenged an executive order issued in September 2021 that required city employees to be vaccinated.

The lawsuit argued that the 14th Amendment protects a right to refuse “investigational” or “new” drugs. It also claimed violations of due process, equal protection, and privacy, along with wrongful termination. The case did not raise a religious freedom claim.

The petition argued that lower courts “failed to address whether the 14th Amendment precludes states and their political subdivisions from mandating the administration of ‘new drugs,'” The Spokesman-Review reported. Attorney David Schexnaydre earlier said his clients were “forced to choose between a rock and a whirlpool.”

In January 2025, U.S. District Judge Barbara Rothstein dismissed all claims. She noted that the FDA had fully approved Pfizer’s COVID-19 vaccine on Aug. 23, 2021, before the mandate took effect, so the vaccine was not investigational. She also found that federal emergency-use and PREP Act provisions do not give individuals a right to sue under civil rights law, and that the mandate did not implicate a fundamental right, according to the district court ruling.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit agreed in May 2026 in an unpublished decision. “We have already concluded that substantially similar mandates, which were imposed for substantially similar reasons, survive rational basis review,” the three-judge panel wrote in its memorandum.

The city waived its right to respond to the petition. No public statement from the city or the plaintiffs’ attorney on the denial was available in the reporting reviewed by MedicalDaily.

A refusal to hear a case does not mean the Supreme Court agreed with the lower courts. According to the Court’s own guidance, a denial “signifies only that the Court has chosen not to accept the case for review and does not express the Court’s view of the merits of the case.” The Court hears arguments in only about 1% of cases filed each term.

Because the denial sets no national precedent, its legal effect is limited to this case, and other courts remain free to reach their own conclusions. The Ninth Circuit’s decision was also unpublished, which means it does not bind future cases in that circuit, though it reflects how the court has treated similar mandates.

The outcome fits a broader pattern. Courts have largely upheld workplace and school vaccine requirements under long-standing precedent. In September, the justices also turned away an emergency request from a New York mother seeking a religious exemption for her kindergartner.

The Bellingham case stems from a 2021 mandate. The denial does not create new rules for current workers, and it does not affect vaccine availability.

For workers, the main lesson is practical. Employer vaccine policies, especially for health care and public safety jobs, often depend on state law, union contracts, and whether medical or religious accommodations are offered. Workers with concerns can review their employer’s written policy, ask about accommodation procedures, and keep copies of any requests.

People with medical concerns about a vaccine should discuss them with a clinician, who can review their health history and any documented reactions. Possible vaccine injuries can be reported to the federal Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System.

The Bellingham workers’ federal case is over, but the denial decides nothing beyond their case, and the debate over mandates and exemptions continues in other courts.

What did the Supreme Court decide? On Oct. 5, it declined to hear Brock v. City of Bellingham, leaving lower court dismissals in place. No justice noted a dissent.

Who brought the case? Eighteen former Bellingham employees, including police officers, firefighters, and EMTs, who lost their jobs after refusing the 2021 mandate, petitioned the Court.

What did the workers argue? They argued the 14th Amendment protects a right to refuse new or investigational drugs and claimed due process and equal protection violations.

Does the denial set a national precedent? No. A denial does not express the Court’s view on the merits and does not bind other courts.

Does this affect vaccine rules today? Not directly. The decision creates no new rules for current workers and does not affect vaccine availability.