Court orders GH¢3.75m reward for whistleblower over Melcom tax evasion disclosures

Court orders GH¢3.75m reward for whistleblower over Melcom tax evasion disclosures

The High Court in Accra has ordered the state to pay a whistleblower GH¢3,749,113.73 for information he provided on alleged tax evasion by the Melcom Group, ruling that his disclosures contributed to additional revenue recoveries.

The ruling, delivered on January 30 by Justice George Aikins Ampiah-Bonney (Jnr.) of the General Jurisdiction Division, directed the Attorney-General, the Ghana Revenue Authority (GRA) and the Economic and Organised Crime Office (EOCO) to pay Ramasamy Ruthurusamy the amount, together with interest.

The court found that the whistleblower's disclosures were linked to further tax recoveries, rejecting the state's position that the additional amounts recovered were unrelated to his information.

It held that a whistleblower only needs to establish that the information provided contributed to the enforcement action, after which the state must demonstrate that the recovery would have been made regardless of the disclosure.

Ruthurusamy, a former Melcom franchisee, entered into a whistleblower agreement with EOCO in April 2014 after reporting suspected tax evasion by the retail group between 2009 and 2014.

Investigations subsequently established a tax liability of GH¢31.87 million, which Melcom paid, alongside a 25 per cent penalty amounting to GH¢7.97 million.

The penalty was transferred to EOCO with the approval of the then Finance Minister. The agency later paid Ruthurusamy GH¢3.19 million, representing approximately 10 per cent of the tax recovered, while retaining the balance to cover its operational costs.

In November 2017, Ruthurusamy signed another agreement, this time with the Ministry of Finance, following disclosures of further alleged irregularities involving import duty evasion, under-declaration of goods and money laundering.

The GRA, working with the National Intelligence Bureau, subsequently investigated the matter, arrested Melcom directors and recovered an additional GH¢34.59 million.

The further recovery brought the total amount collected from Melcom for the period between 2009 and 2019 to GH¢69.36 million.

However, when Ruthurusamy sought 10 per cent of the additional amount recovered, the GRA declined, arguing that it had already fulfilled its obligation through the earlier payment made by EOCO.

The disagreement resulted in a lawsuit filed by the whistleblower in January 2021.

In its judgment, the court awarded him GH¢3,749,113.73, representing 10 per cent of GH¢37.49 million it determined had been recovered through his disclosures.

It further directed that interest be calculated at the commercial rate from December 29, 2017. However, the court rejected his separate claim of GH¢340,000 for printing expenses, describing the amount as unreasonable.

The court also found that the practice of paying whistleblower rewards directly from recovered funds, rather than through the statutory Whistleblower Reward Fund, was unlawful.

Section 24 of the Whistleblower Act provides that individuals whose disclosures lead to the recovery of funds are entitled to rewards paid from the Fund. The reward is set at 10 per cent of the recovered amount or another figure determined by the Attorney-General in consultation with the Inspector-General of Police.

Consequently, EOCO has been directed to transfer the outstanding GH¢4.78 million balance of the earlier penalty into the Fund, with any future rewards arising from the Melcom recoveries to be paid exclusively through that statutory arrangement.

The ruling comes amid continuing GRA efforts to enforce tax compliance among retailers, including previous tax stamp operations involving Melcom and recent VAT compliance inspections at the Achimota Retail Centre.

A
Ama Serwaa Staff Journalist

Business & Economic Affairs Lead at Ghanamma. Specializes in Bank of Ghana monetary policy, Cedi benchmarks, and West African markets.

Ghanamma Editorial Standards: This report has been prepared and verified in accordance with Ghanamma.com's editorial code of ethics. Factual inquiries, right of reply, or corrections may be submitted directly to our newsroom at info@ghanamma.com. 📰 Syndicated wire assistance & reporting credit: Modern Ghana.
Share: WhatsApp WhatsApp
💬

Comments (0)

Join the Conversation

No comments yet. Be the first to share your opinion!

You may like