Farmer-Herder Clashes: Why Peace Remains Elusive

Farmer-Herder Clashes: Why Peace Remains Elusive

No Result View All Result Home News Politics Business Sport Football Health Entertainment Education Opinion Editorial Columns Others LeVogue Magazine Conferences National Economy Contact Us Hausa Edition Home News Politics Business Sport Football Health Entertainment Education Opinion Editorial Columns Others LeVogue Magazine Conferences National Economy Contact Us No Result View All Result No Result View All Result Farmer-Herder Clashes: Why Peace Remains Elusive by Sola Ojo 6 seconds ago in Cover Stories, News Share on WhatsAppShare on FacebookShare on XTelegram BY SOLA OJO, ACHOR ABIMAJE, FRANCIS OKOYE, EMMANUEL MGBEAHURIKE, FELIX IGBEKOYI, DELE OGUNYEMI, AZA MSUE, KABIR WURMA AND KALU From dialogue and peace agreements to grazing restrictions, security deployments and ranching plans, states across Nigeria are adopting different strategies to contain recurring clashes between farmers and herders.

Yet, as communities continue to report destroyed crops, blocked grazing routes, displacement and attacks, the search for lasting peace remains elusive.

Findings by LEADERSHIP across Kaduna, Plateau, Borno, Imo, Delta, Benue, Cross River, Gombe, Niger, Osun and Kebbi states show that governments are combining traditional mediation, stakeholder engagement, enforcement of anti-open-grazing laws and livestock management reforms.

While some states are restoring designated cattle routes and grazing reserves, others are strengthening security operations and encouraging farmers and pastoralists to resolve disputes before they escalate.

The conflict, rooted in competition for land, water and other natural resources, has been aggravated by population growth, pressure on farmland, climate change, proliferation of small arms and the breakdown of traditional conflict-resolution mechanisms. In some areas, disputes have also acquired ethnic and religious dimensions, deepening mistrust between communities.

Reports from various sources estimate that about 6,439 people were killed between 2019 and 2026 in violence linked to farmer-herder clashes and reprisals, with Benue, Plateau, Nasarawa, Taraba, Kaduna and Niger among the worst-affected states.

However, experiences across the states show that temporary interventions may not guarantee lasting peace without effective enforcement, protection of livelihoods, fair access to land and accountability for criminal acts.

KADUNA: Communities Seek Dialogue, Land Protection

In Kaduna State, farming and pastoralist leaders are calling for sustained dialogue, respect for land rights and greater involvement of traditional institutions.

The national president of the Southern Kaduna Peoples Union (SOKAPU), Dr Samuel Tabara Kato, and his counterpart in the Gan Allah Fulani Development Association of Nigeria (GAFDAN), Dr Ibrahim Abdullahi, offered different perspectives but agreed on the importance of engagement.

Abdullahi attributed the relative peace recorded in the state over the past two to three years to stakeholder engagement and peaceful conflict resolution. He said dialogue between farmers and herders, supported by the Kaduna State Peace Commission established by the previous administration, had helped prevent disagreements from degenerating into violence.

Kato, however, questioned the description of some attacks as farmer-herder clashes, alleging that certain incidents involved attacks on farming communities, destruction of crops and displacement of residents from their ancestral lands.

Although he acknowledged a reduction in attacks, Kato said he was unaware of any mediation agreement involving affected communities. He also alleged that powerful cattle owners and influential interests were exploiting the situation.

A senior government official and farm owner in Kachia called for sustained dialogue and greater involvement of traditional rulers, citing their knowledge of local communities, cultural practices and influence over residents.

Efforts to obtain comments from the Kaduna State Police Command spokesperson, DSP Mansir Hassan, were unsuccessful.

PLATEAU: Grazing Disputes Deepen Calls For Tougher Action

In Plateau State, disagreements over grazing routes, land ownership and implementation of previous peace agreements continue to complicate efforts to end tensions.

The state chairman of the Miyetti Allah Cattle Breeders Association of Nigeria (MACBAN), Yusuf Babayo, said many traditional cattle routes had been blocked. He urged governments at all levels to ensure justice and fairness for farmers and herders.

However, the president of the Berom Youth Moulders (BYM), Barrister Solomon Nwatiri, accused Fulani herders of repeatedly violating peace agreements.

Nwatiri alleged that more than 90 communities and their farmlands in Riyom and Barkin Ladi Local Government Areas had been taken over by what he described as Fulani land grabbers. He called for a ban on open grazing and the deployment of security personnel to flush out bandits and other criminal elements.

A Barkin Ladi resident, Musa Amos, also advocated regular dialogue involving the government, farmers and herders. He supported a ban on open grazing to prevent cattle from destroying crops.

Governor Caleb Mutfwang has rejected the description of the violence as mere farmer-herder clashes, characterising the attacks as organised criminality and terrorism. He alleged that some perpetrators were pursuing an economic war and land-grabbing strategy designed to prevent farmers from cultivating their land and push them into poverty.

Meanwhile, the media and information Offĺicer of Operation Enduring Peace (OPEP), Captain Polycarp Oteh, said security agencies were deploying personnel to volatile communities to prevent further attacks and maintain peace.

BORNO: Committee Report Offers Hope For Farmers

In Borno State, the government is considering recommendations from a committee established to investigate recurring disputes between farmers and herders.

The president of the All Farmers Association of Nigeria (AFAN), Borno State chapter, Alhaji Allamin Umara Lawan, said the Commissioner for Agriculture and relevant security agencies had been briefed on tensions in Askira-Uba and Magumeri Local Government Areas.

He explained that Governor Babagana Zulum constituted the committee to identify the causes of the conflicts and recommend practical solutions.

According to Lawan, the committee spent two to three months engaging farmers and herders in affected communities before submitting its report to the governor through its chairman.

He expressed optimism that the recommendations would restore peace and protect farming activities.

However, a video circulating online showing more than 50 cows entering a farmland in Askira-Uba has raised fresh concerns. In the footage, a male voice appealed to herders to give farmers about 30 minutes to gather their harvested crops before bringing in the cattle. Herders were also heard asking for patience.

The incident highlights the need for practical arrangements to regulate cattle movement and protect crops, particularly during harvest.

IMO: Government Intervention Brings Relative Calm

In Imo State, government intervention and security operations appear to have reduced tensions, but affected communities say more needs to be done to protect farmers.

The President-General of Amulu Ihitte, Chief Austin Egejuru, urged the government to caution herders against encroaching on farmlands.

While acknowledging government efforts to provide relief to affected residents, he insisted that interventions must be sustained. He said farmers had suffered more than herders, creating an imbalance that continued to hinder peaceful coexistence.

In Agwa, some farmers alleged that fear of attacks and herders’ activities had forced residents to abandon their farms. They also claimed that herders had taken over areas previously used for cultivation, restricting farmers’ access to their land.

They called for stronger government intervention to restore confidence and enable them to return to their farms.

DELTA: Mediation Struggles To Restore Farmers’ Confidence

In Delta State, mediation agreements and anti-grazing regulations have been introduced, but confidence among farming communities remains fragile.

The government had previously disarmed armed herders and arrested underage herders as part of efforts to enforce its anti-grazing laws. However, setbacks in implementing mediation agreements have reportedly left some farmers apprehensive about returning to their farmlands.

The special adviser to Governor Sheriff Oborevwori on Peacebuilding and Conflict Resolution, Chief Edwin Uzor, advocated ranching and stricter enforcement of anti-grazing regulations.

He called for task forces to monitor entry points, profile herders, identify hideouts used by armed herders and restructure Operation Delta Sweep to tackle criminal elements.

Uzor urged herders to respect host communities and residents to operate within the law, insisting that genuine pastoralists should be allowed to coexist peacefully with their hosts.

The special adviser to the governor on Livestock and Inter-Ethnic Relations, Chief Jeffrey Azagba, proposed a farmers-herders dialogue forum to resolve disagreements before they escalate into violence. He described both groups as partners in food security and sustainable development.

The Police Public Relations Officer, Bright Edafe, also urged herders to respect their host communities and residents to abide by the law.

However, reports of fresh violence have raised questions about the sustainability of the peace efforts.

In Umunede and Mbiri communities in Ika North-East Local Government Area, two farmers were reportedly killed by suspected herders, triggering a reprisal attack.

Angry youths reportedly stormed a herders’ settlement in Umunede, destroying property and burning about four motorcycles. A source said the victims were attacked along Idumu-Ikeze Quarters farm road and Mbiri farm settlement road.

The incidents heightened fears of renewed violence and underscored the need for continuous security monitoring and enforcement of peace agreements.

In Benue State, the police say they are strengthening engagement with residents and pastoralists to prevent disputes from escalating into attacks.

The measures focus on communities bordering Nasarawa and Taraba states, as well as Agatu, Gwer West, Gwer East, Guma, Logo, Ukum, Katsina-Ala and Kwande local government areas.

The State Police Command spokesperson, DSP Peter Orchia Aondongu, said officers had engaged community leaders and sensitised farmers and herders on resolving disagreements through lawful channels.

He said herders had been warned against entering farmlands without permission, while farmers had been advised to report trespass and crop destruction to the police rather than resort to self-help.

Aondongu said anyone found trespassing on or destroying another person’s farm would face the law. He maintained that the measures had reduced clashes to the barest minimum and helped build confidence among affected communities.

Efforts to obtain comments from relevant community associations, including MACBAN, were unsuccessful.

CROSS RIVER: Law On Grazing Faces Enforcement Test

In Cross River State, cattle entering farms, destroying crops and triggering retaliation continue to threaten farming communities despite the existence of a law regulating livestock movement.

In Odukpani, Bekwarra, Biase and Yala, disputes have reportedly resulted in deaths, fear and abandonment of farmlands. In July 2024, women from Ukpada in Bekwarra protested over the destruction of their farms, while lawmakers expressed concern that farmers were afraid to visit their fields because herders allegedly carried dangerous weapons.

The state adopted a livestock and grazing management law under former Governor Ben Ayade. The legislation provides for designated ranching areas, penalties for cattle straying into farms and transportation of cattle by vehicles rather than trekking through farmlands.

However, weak enforcement has undermined its effectiveness. Following fresh destruction of farms in Bekwarra, the Cross River State House of Assembly again directed the government to implement the law.

Under Governor Bassey Otu, the state has shifted towards ranching, pasture development and mediation. Its plans include livestock clusters and a Border Animal Holding and Quarantine Facility at Mfum-Ajassor in Etung, alongside stakeholders’ committees and profiling of herders in Odukpani-Qua.

A farmer in Ikom, Asu Nentui, reportedly complained that cattle had destroyed his crops, arguing that legislation without enforcement and provision of ranches would not end the cycle of destruction and retaliation.

Other states are also pursuing livestock reforms. Ebonyi is developing a 292-hectare ranch at Izziangbo, while Enugu is establishing an integrated livestock centre at Owo designed for 15,000 cattle. Gombe has restricted night grazing and children’s involvement in cattle management.

GOMBE: Cattle Routes Return To The Agenda

Gombe State has tightened restrictions on cattle movement until January 2027, deployed monitoring teams at designated entry points and began efforts to restore 37 cattle routes and eight grazing reserves.

The measures are intended to protect farmlands and prevent confrontations during the harvest season. The government has directed conflict-resolution committees in all 11 local government areas to monitor cattle movement and warned herders against night grazing and allowing underage children to oversee cattle.

Farmers have also been cautioned against burning crop residues and transporting agricultural produce at night. Both MACBAN and AFAN have urged their members to comply.

The state has established a task force to monitor activities, receive complaints and work with security agencies and vigilante groups. Sensitisation exercises in Nafada and Funakaye have included plans to document herders through local Ardos.

Officials said initial engagements had recorded no farmer-herder clashes, while pastoralist leaders welcomed the interventions but called for the restoration of grazing reserves and cattle routes they said had been encroached upon.

AFAN Chairman in Gombe, Modibbo Sadiq Ahmad Nafada, told LEADERSHIP that enforcement remained challenging, particularly because some herders carried sophisticated weapons. Nevertheless, he said no notable clashes had been recorded.

He disclosed that the committee was considering escorting incoming herders along designated cattle routes rather than turning them back, to monitor their movements and reduce the risk of disputes.

NIGER: Government Moves To Restore 23 Grazing Routes

In Niger State, deadly clashes in Baji community in Gurara Local Government Area and in Rafi and Agwara have prompted the government to begin efforts to reactivate 23 grazing routes.

The incidents reportedly claimed several lives, including that of a young farmer in Baji.

Governor Mohammed Umaru Bago, who visited the affected areas, held meetings with traditional rulers and community leaders. He warned village heads against allocating land indiscriminately without approval from relevant authorities and stressed the need for proper demarcation.

He said restoring grazing routes would reduce clashes if farmers and herders respected boundaries and avoided encroaching on one another’s land.

However, it remained unclear whether the routes had been fully reactivated or whether the Ministry of Nomadic Affairs had developed an implementation framework. Attempts to obtain clarification from the Commissioner, Alhaji Umar Ahmed Sanda Rebe, were unsuccessful.

OSUN: Dialogue Becomes A Regular Peace Strategy

In Osun State, the government has adopted regular dialogue and early-warning mechanisms to prevent disagreements between farmers and herders from escalating into violence.

The Senior Special Adviser to Governor Ademola Adeleke, Adebisi Moruf Abiodun, said the government, in collaboration with Justice Development and Peace Makers, had consistently organised biannual stakeholders’ peacebuilding meetings.

She explained that the meetings provided a platform for farmers, herders and other stakeholders to discuss disputes and develop community-led early-warning mechanisms.

The government has also appointed liaison officers to alert it to impending clashes, enabling prompt intervention.

Abiodun said the latest programme, held in Osogbo on 29 July 2026, attracted representatives of the NSCDC Agro Rangers Unit, the Seriki Fulani of Osun State, local Seriki Fulani, the MACBAN state chairman and the Sustainable Farmers Association, among other groups.

In Kebbi State, the government says stronger security measures and prompt intervention have significantly reduced farmer-herder clashes.

The last major incident reported to LEADERSHIP occurred in Alhannare, Bagudo Local Government Area, where some residents lost their lives.

Governor Nasir Idris subsequently visited the community, sympathised with victims’ families and ordered the deployment of additional security personnel.

A MACBAN member in the area, who spoke anonymously, commended the governor for his prompt intervention whenever clashes occurred.

The director of security, Cabinet Office, Birnin Kebbi, Abdulrahman Usman Zagga, also said criminal activities, including communal disputes between farmers and herders, had declined considerably following the government’s security measures.

THE CHALLENGE: TURNING TEMPORARY CALM INTO LASTING PEACE

Experiences across the states show that no single intervention can resolve farmer-herder clashes everywhere.

Kaduna and Osun emphasise dialogue and early-warning systems; Plateau is demanding stronger security action and addressing disputes over grazing routes; Borno is relying on committee recommendations, while Gombe and Niger are pursuing the restoration of cattle routes and grazing reserves. Delta and Cross River are combining anti-grazing enforcement, ranching and mediation.

However, recurring complaints from farmers and pastoralists point to a wider problem: agreements and laws mean little without effective enforcement, public trust and accountability for attacks and destruction of property.

We’ve got the edge. Get real-time reports, breaking scoops, and exclusive angles delivered straight to your phone. Don’t settle for stale news. Join LEADERSHIP NEWS on WhatsApp for 24/7 updates →

📰 Original Source Attribution

Reported by leadership.ng.

Read Original Report at leadership.ng ↗
Share: WhatsApp WhatsApp
💬

Comments (0)

Join the Conversation

No comments yet. Be the first to share your opinion!

You may like