Tuesday briefing: Andy Burnham’s government wants to get young people into work. Will cutting their benefits help?
The government’s review proposes major changes to benefits and employment support for young people. Photograph: Bloomberg/Getty ImagesView image in fullscreenThe government’s review proposes major changes to benefits and employment support for young people. Photograph: Bloomberg/Getty ImagesTuesday briefing: Andy Burnham’s government wants to get young people into work. Will cutting their benefits help?In today’s newsletter: Guaranteed jobs and expanded employment support sit alongside Alan Milburn’s proposals to cut benefits for some of Britain’s million young people not in education, work or training
Good morning. The former health secretary, Alan Milburn, will publish his long-awaited review into the one million young people not in education, employment or training (Neets) later today. The report will propose cutting welfare for some under-25s and spending billions on a new “deal” for young people. The government is at pains to tell you that its approach to welfare is nothing like that of the Tories’: Labour isn’t the party of “crude” benefit cuts, and it sees youth worklessness as a “moral” issue for which young people aren’t to blame.
It’s hard to recall a government report more heavily trailed than this one. It envisages a new relationship between young people and the state, and aims to get more young people into work and education while addressing the cost of young people becoming Neets. But will it work? For today’s First Edition, I spoke to the Guardian’s economics correspondent Richard Partington for a no-nonsense guide to all the things the government will say about this review, and how we should assess their arguments. First, here are the headlines.
UK | The Ministry of Justice has launched an investigation into whether Russell Brand has broken prison rules after the jailed comedian shared a message claiming he was not guilty of sexual offences just days after his conviction.
Israel | The Israeli military uploaded 3.5m photos to Amazon’s cloud platform in order to use the US company’s facial recognition technology to analyse images of Palestinians, the Guardian can reveal.
EU | Five EU member states have announced plans to set up an offshore centre in Rwanda for people with no legal right to stay in Europe, in a pilot scheme that is expected to face legal challenges and has been denounced as “a grave moral failing”.
UK news | Police chiefs say officers are “retreating from the streets” amid the worst financial crisis in decades, which has left nine forces seeking exceptional financial support (EFS) from the government.
Technology | Microsoft has identified the root causes of the global outage that crippled Outlook, Exchange and a host of other vital office software last week.
View image in fullscreenYoung people not in education, employment or training have long been a concern for policymakers. Photograph: Martin Godwin/The GuardianRemember when Keir Starmer’s government was forced to back-track last year after backbench Labour MPs voted against its controversial welfare reform bill, which proposed cutting personal independence payments (Pip)? Andy Burnham’s government is keen to avoid a repeat of that scenario, and Milburn has been assiduously trying to win over Labour MPs, as Pippa Crerar wrote yesterday. “The government is taking on an incredibly thorny issue, but they’re presenting this as a way to inject hope for the next generation,” Richard says. “They’re offsetting the negative stuff with a vast increase in employment support.”
Journalists will spend much of this week asking whether Milburn and Burnham have succeeded where Starmer failed. But the real test of their proposals lies far beyond SW1. Neets have been a concern for policymakers since the 1990s, and their number is now higher than ever. Among comparable European nations, only Romania had a higher Neet rate than Britain in 2025. The problem is also unevenly distributed: the likelihood of becoming Neet is (unsurprisingly) far higher in places like Blackpool than in the Cotswolds.
The report tries to address two problems. One is economic: more than a third of Neets do not claim benefits, but the cost of supporting those who do is high. Milburn estimates that £3.2bn of welfare spending on young people who are Neet could be avoided if they were in work. The other is more complex, and reflects a sense of generational despondency among young people, many of whom are “struggling to stay in sync with society at large”, as William Davies wrote in an interesting piece earlier this year (£).
Big changes to welfare for young people: The report proposes the largest overhaul of the benefits system since the creation of universal credit in 2013. It suggests replacing Pip for under-25s and the health element of universal credit with a new “youth allowance”, which would be paid at the standard rate of UC.
Guaranteed work: In exchange for losing access to their benefits, the government will “guarantee” eligible 18-to-24-year-olds a fully funded, six-month job. This builds on the Starmer government’s jobs guarantee, which was meant to be available to people who had been claiming UC for 18 months. The new proposals would extend eligibility for this to people who have been claiming UC for 12 months.
More support for young people and employers: Instant (albeit digital) access to mental health support will be provided for young people who are Neet. Employers that hire people who have been Neet for six months will get a payment of £3,000, and the government is also expected to lower national insurance payments by businesses for employees aged between 21 and 24 for a five-year period, starting in retail and hospitality sectors.
What are some of the arguments in favour of these proposals?
Young people don’t want to be out of work. About 84% of young people who are Neet say they want to find a job, education or training. “Being out of work has a huge impact on your sense of wellbeing and mental health, and your finances,” Richard says. A 24-year-old who has never had a job will lose an estimated £300,000 in earnings over their lifetime, even after they enter the labour market. Milburn is proposing an “opportunity” guarantee, giving people support into education, training and work, and a “support” guarantee, allowing them to take this opportunity up. Expect more details on those later today.
Helping young people prepare for work is pointless if nobody wants to hire them. Milburn is expected to make a variation of this argument today. Young people now make up about 40% of the headline unemployment figures, partly because many employers aren’t willing to take a risk on them. But there’s also a risk that paying firms to employ people will benefit companies that would have hired them anyway, effectively handing public money to large corporations that really don’t need it.“Employers have a social responsibility,” Richard says. “But they often make a kneejerk argument for tax cuts and deregulation.”
If you don’t tackle this, your enemies will tackle it for you. The Department for Work and Pensions currently spends 25 times as much on benefits for young people than it does on employment support, something that many MPs believe is unsustainable, even if they find it hard to swallow cuts. “For Labour, there’s a danger that because welfare reform is difficult, it means it should never be touched,” Richard says. “You can imagine a different government taking a very different approach to this.”
What are some of the arguments against them?
Cutting benefits is unnecessary. While the review is being sold as an opportunity for young people, there’s no getting away from the fact that many young people will lose their benefits. About 184,000 young people aged 16 to 24 receive the universal credit health element, some of whom have complex needs that prohibit them from working. Benefits aren’t the cause of people becoming Neet, and if the government was solely interested in creating opportunities for young people, it could do so without cutting welfare. As more people enter the labour market, the number of people on benefits will reduce.
Work doesn’t pay. Governments often treat the labour market as a solution to the rising welfare bill while ignoring the reality of modern work. In-work poverty has been rising over the last decade and many benefit claimants have been forced into low-paid, part-time jobs on zero-hours contracts. As Richard noted earlier this week, countless studies connect badly paid work to poor mental wellbeing. In other words, it’s not enough to funnel young people into jobs. The pay, conditions and quality of those jobs also matter.
Neets are symptomatic of bigger problems. The rate of Neets is higher in disadvantaged and deindustrialised areas where there are fewer jobs. “If there aren’t jobs to go to, what chance of success do you have?” Richard says. In that sense, the proposed changes risk hitting the most disadvantaged the hardest. For the Milburn report’s proposals to work, Richard believes they will need to form part of a wider strategy to create prosperity in places outside the UK’s major cities. Otherwise, the government will simply be managing the consequences of an economic crisis, rather than addressing its cause.
View image in fullscreenNot ready for the cold and dark? Maybe you need a ‘winter transition week’, Emma Beddington writes. Photograph: Toby Melville/Reuters I learned today about the concept of a “winter transition” in Emma Beddington’s column. It’s something I think we all could benefit from – If only, as Emma quite rightly points out, we all get time to transition back out again at the end. Poppy Noor, newsletters team
The head of Women’s Aid, Farah Nazeer, gives an insightful interview on the new frontlines of the sexual violence crisis, and how technology is “providing new mechanisms of abuse”. Sundus Abdi, newsletters team
Mr Baxter chewed through Camilla Balshaw’s silk scarf, shoes, trainers gloves and flat caps. Her essay for The pet I’ll never forget series is a lesson in the things we go through for our dogs – and how, with the right training, we can start to unlock things we once thought were impossible. Poppy
In the past year, far-right intimidation and flag campaigns have inspired grassroots anti-racism organising across England. Aamna Mohdin speaks to some of the organisers behind the hopeful campaigns. Sundus
Spaghetti bolognese is the meal I would ask for on my last day on this earth, so I very much enjoyed Ben Aitken’s feature on his search for the perfect plate in Bologna – and I might just take him up on some of his recommendations – when I can next afford a holiday, that is. Poppy
View image in fullscreenLewis Ferguson looks dejected after scoring Switzerland’s opener with an own goal. Photograph: Romina Amato/ReutersFootball | Lewis Ferguson’s first-half own goal set Switzerland on their way to a 4-0 victory as Scotland finished third in their Nations League group. Meanwhile Germany delivered a 5-0 rout of the Netherlands, reaching the Nations League quarter-finals as group winners.
Rubgy | Will Joseph is poised to be rewarded for his five-try heroics against Japan with another England start against New Zealand on Saturday.
Ice hockey | The United States beat Canada 6-2 to win the women’s ice hockey world championship in Herning, Denmark, becoming the first US team to capture Olympic and world titles in the same calendar year.
View image in fullscreen Photograph: The Guardian“Police ‘retreating from streets’ as funding crisis grows, warns chiefs”, is the Guardian’s splash today.
The Mail has “Labour IS to blame for youth jobs crisis”, the Telegraph says “No savings for a decade in Milburn’s benefits plan”, the i Paper’s take is “UK firms demand tax cut to hire more under-25s – as the price for supporting Burnham’s big plan”, and Metro says “Can we fix it? YOS WE CAN”.
The Times writes “UK will face penalties if Brexit reset is scrapped”, and the Express has “Ditch Brexit reset talks and get on with real work”. The FT leads on “Nvidia rejects bid to reinstate Huang despite Trump backing for reprieve”.
The Mirror has “We’ve not been expecting you, Mr Bond”, and the Sun on the same story writes “The name’s Patz … R-Patz”.
View image in fullscreen Photograph: The GuardianFloods and bombings: Deadly winter approaches in Gaza
Deadly floods in Gaza have created a dire humanitarian crisis, as the governments of Australia, Canada, the UK and Italy call on Israel to allow the safe passage of critical aid to civilians before winter sets in. Tens of thousands of Palestinians in Gaza have been left in waterlogged and damaged tents, with sanitation infrastructure also destroyed by storms. Supplies including food, medicine and water and 150,000 tents are being held by Israel at the border, while the UN warns of the spread of diseases. Lucy Hough speaks to the Guardian’s chief Middle East correspondent, Emma Graham-Harrison.
View image in fullscreen Illustration: Ben Jennings/The GuardianThe UpsideA bit of good news to remind you that the world’s not all bad
View image in fullscreen‘After just a few weeks, I was hooked.’ … Georgina Lawton at Queens in west London. Photograph: Ethan Parker/The GuardianWhen Georgina Lawton returned to England after a four and a half year stint away in Lisbon, it was depressing at first. She returned in winter, to higher prices and faster pace of life, and a new diagnosis made everything feel that little bit harder. That’s until she picked up a new hobby: ice-skating.
Grabbing some skates and heading to the rink twice a week vastly improved the way she experienced life. Suddenly, life felt full of progress and social connection – and the structure helped with a feeling of aimlessness. She went and bought her first pair of proper skates, and found herself with a new friendship group, aged anywhere from 15-60.
“Friends who had always said I was “all or nothing” joked that I would drop my new hobby when things got tough, but I persisted,” says Lawton.
Sign up here for a weekly roundup of The Upside, sent to you every Sunday
And finally, the Guardian’s puzzles are here to keep you entertained throughout the day. Until tomorrow.
Reported by theguardian.com.
Read Original Report at theguardian.com ↗
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share your opinion!