President Ramaphosa tells Elon Musk to remember South Africa as billionaire fires back with explosive racism accusation
President Cyril Ramaphosa has urged Elon Musk to remember the country where he grew up, saying the billionaire does not fully understand the damage apartheid caused to black South Africans.
The comments have opened a fresh political and public dispute between the South African president and the technology entrepreneur, who was born in Pretoria and later became one of the world’s most prominent business figures.
Speaking to ABC News journalist Jonathan Karl at the Semafor Silicon Valley & The World summit in Menlo Park, California, on Monday, Ramaphosa said Musk owed some loyalty to the country that gave him his early education and opportunities.
“Even as one is a citizen of a new country, you should still be loyal to your own country,” Ramaphosa said.
[do_widget id=super_rss_reader-3] –> –> Musk responded on X, accusing South Africa of discrimination against minority groups.
“South Africa is now super racist against whites and Asians.”
“I have met Elon Musk in the past, and I’ve been awed by his brilliance. But I’d also like to chat to him about remembering his country,” South African President Cyril Ramaphosa tells @jonkarl.
“What you’ve become today is by dint of your own origins … It is because of the knowledge. And the education that was made available to him.”
The exchange comes as relations between Musk and South Africa remain tense over the country’s transformation policies and the decision not to allow Starlink, Musk’s satellite internet service, to operate locally.
Starlink uses a network of satellites to provide internet access, including in areas where traditional fixed-line or mobile networks may be limited. The company operates in many countries, but it has not launched a commercial service in South Africa.
Ramaphosa said Starlink’s absence was linked to South Africa’s laws and policies governing companies that want to operate in the country. He said Musk had struggled to understand the policy position.
@semafor @jonkarl South Africa is now super racist against Whites and Asians
— Elon Musk (@elonmusk) November 17, 2026
The president was referring in part to black economic empowerment, commonly known as BEE. The policy framework seeks to address the economic exclusion created by apartheid by widening ownership, management and opportunity for black South Africans.
Musk has criticised BEE and described it as “openly racist”. His objections have placed him on the opposite side of a long-running national debate about how South Africa should correct the inequalities left by apartheid.
The government argues that race-based economic measures are necessary because apartheid deliberately denied black South Africans access to quality education, land, jobs, businesses and wealth. Critics argue that some policies can be unfair or create barriers for companies and individuals who were not personally responsible for apartheid.
The argument over Starlink has therefore become part of a much larger disagreement about equality, investment and redress. For the government, a foreign or multinational company must follow South African rules. For Musk and his supporters, the requirements may be viewed as discriminatory and an obstacle to investment.
Ramaphosa used his own educational experience to explain why he believed Musk had failed to understand the issue. The president, who was imprisoned as a young anti-apartheid activist, said the apartheid state had invested far more in Musk’s education than in his own.
“If one does not understand that one will never be able to understand precisely what needs to be done to remedy the harm that was done,” he said.
Ramaphosa said the state had spent roughly R1 on his education for every R12 it had spent on Musk’s. The comparison was intended to show the unequal opportunities created by apartheid, rather than to suggest that individual success was solely determined by government spending.
Musk grew up in South Africa before moving abroad and building a business career that included companies such as Tesla, SpaceX and the social-media platform X. His background in South Africa has remained part of political debates, particularly when he comments on race, government policy and the country’s treatment of white people.
Musk has increasingly used X to express views on South African politics and international affairs. His comments about the country being “super racist against whites and Asians” are likely to intensify the disagreement with Ramaphosa’s government.
The president’s remarks also come after an earlier clash involving United States President Donald Trump. Last year, Ramaphosa visited Trump in the Oval Office, where Trump accused South Africa of persecuting white Afrikaners.
Trump displayed video footage and press clippings that he said supported claims about attacks and discrimination against white South Africans. Ramaphosa rejected the presentation and later described the meeting as an ambush.
In Monday’s interview, he said the material shown by Trump did not depict South Africa and that the US president had been misinformed.
“We are Nelson Mandela’s children, and we respect the human rights of everyone – black, white, everyone. We never target any national group for either persecution or genocide. It will never happen in South Africa,” Ramaphosa said.
The statement was a direct response to claims that South Africa’s government is targeting white people. Ramaphosa said South Africa’s constitutional order protects everyone and that the country does not pursue persecution or genocide against any national group.
The debate has international consequences because it is taking place alongside worsening relations between South Africa and the United States. The relationship has been affected by cuts to US aid, the collapse or weakening of trade arrangements, disagreements over foreign policy and Trump’s decision to skip the G20.
The United States has also granted refugee status to Afrikaners, a move welcomed by some groups but criticised by the South African government and others who say it gives credibility to claims of a racial campaign that has not been established.
At the same time, South Africa is seeking investment, improved digital access and stronger international trade links. Starlink’s potential entry into the local market has therefore attracted interest from people who believe satellite internet could help schools, rural communities and small businesses.
Supporters of Starlink argue that the service could improve competition and connect places where fibre or mobile networks are too expensive or unavailable. Opponents of changing BEE requirements warn that removing transformation rules would allow companies to benefit from the South African market without helping to correct historical exclusion.
The government has not said that Starlink is permanently barred from South Africa. The issue is whether the company will meet the country’s regulatory and transformation requirements before operating commercially.
Ramaphosa’s comments suggest that the administration does not intend to create a special exemption for Musk. His message was that Starlink, like any other company, must follow South African law if it wants to do business in the country.
Musk’s response suggests that he sees the policy as discriminatory. The two positions remain far apart, and the latest exchange does not appear to have moved either side closer to agreement.
The political dispute also carries a personal element. Ramaphosa was speaking to a global audience about a South African who achieved extraordinary success after leaving the country. Musk, meanwhile, has used a large international platform to criticise the government and defend the interests of white and Asian South Africans.
Whether the argument changes Starlink’s position remains uncertain. Any future application would have to be assessed by South African regulators under the relevant laws. It would also have to address concerns about licensing, spectrum, national security, consumer protection and economic transformation.
For ordinary South Africans, the dispute is not only about personalities. It touches on the cost and availability of internet access, the country’s attempt to overcome apartheid’s legacy and the question of whether companies should be required to contribute to redress.
The exchange also shows how domestic policy debates can become international diplomatic issues. A comment on X can affect perceptions of South Africa abroad, while statements by the president can influence investors and technology companies considering the market.
Ramaphosa’s appeal that Musk should remember his country reflects the president’s broader argument that South Africa’s history must be understood before its current policies are judged. Musk’s response reflects a competing view that present-day policies can themselves create discrimination.
The disagreement is unlikely to end with one interview or one social-media post. The South African government must still defend its transformation rules, while Musk and Starlink must decide whether meeting those rules is commercially and politically acceptable.
For now, the relationship between the two men remains openly strained. Ramaphosa says Musk does not understand apartheid’s impact and should show loyalty to the country that shaped him. Musk says South Africa has become racist towards whites and Asians.
The Starlink question remains unresolved, but the larger argument is clear: South Africa’s past continues to shape its laws, its business environment and its relations with some of the world’s most powerful people.
Close Privacy Overview This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience. Necessary Necessary Always Enabled Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information. Non-necessary Non-necessary Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website. SAVE & ACCEPT Loading Comments… You must be logged in to post a comment.
Reported by celebgossip.co.za.
Read Original Report at celebgossip.co.za ↗
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share your opinion!