KSh117 Billion Could Have Been Saved: World Bank Exposes Kenya’s Costly SGR Project
Fresh findings by the World Bank suggest that Kenya could have saved up to US$900 million, approximately KSh117 billion, during the initial construction of the Mombasa–Naivasha railway if stronger governance measures and competitive procurement procedures had been adopted.
The findings have raised questions about how the project was planned, awarded and implemented, particularly as taxpayers continue to shoulder the financial burden of servicing loans used to finance the railway.
According to the World Bank’s latest Kenya Economic Update, the country’s railway construction costs were significantly higher than those of comparable projects in neighbouring countries.
Kenya’s diesel-powered railway from Mombasa to Nairobi cost approximately KSh988 million per kilometre. By comparison, Tanzania’s electrified railway linking Dar es Salaam to Dodoma cost about KSh741 million per kilometre, while the electrified Djibouti–Addis Ababa line cost approximately KSh689 million per kilometre.
Although the World Bank acknowledged that railway construction costs are influenced by differences in terrain, technical requirements and other project-specific factors, it identified governance weaknesses as a significant contributor to Kenya’s higher expenditure.
The report estimates that at least 30 per cent of the potential savings, approximately KSh35 billion, was linked to governance challenges rather than technical or geographical differences.
Among the issues highlighted by the World Bank are the preference for direct contracting instead of competitive tendering, land speculation and alleged fraud involving land titles, property valuation and compensation payments.
These concerns suggest that weaknesses in procurement and land acquisition may have increased the amount Kenya spent on the project.
The initial Mombasa–Nairobi railway was constructed by China Road and Bridge Corporation (CRBC), with financing largely provided through loans from the Export-Import Bank of China.
The contractor also conducted the project’s feasibility study, which was approved by Kenya Railways Corporation. This arrangement has attracted scrutiny because of concerns about the independence of project assessment and the level of competition in the procurement process.
Kenya borrowed approximately KSh649.9 billion in loans between 2014 and 2015 to finance the railway’s construction from Mombasa through Nairobi to Naivasha.
However, the financial burden has continued to grow, partly because of interest and delayed repayments.
By November 2024, the original loan amount of KSh539 billion had increased to approximately KSh737.5 billion, according to findings cited in a Transparency International Kenya report.
The concerns surrounding the SGR are not limited to construction costs.
A separate assessment by Transparency International Kenya, released in June 2026, identified the railway as the highest corruption-risk project among three major infrastructure developments examined.
Using its Infrastructure Corruption Risk Assessment Tool, the organisation gave the SGR a vulnerability score of 4.49 out of five, placing it in the very high-risk category.
The assessment identified limited transparency in procurement, secrecy surrounding contractual agreements, weak public participation and inadequate disclosure of project costs and financing arrangements as major concerns.
It also questioned the extent of parliamentary oversight during the planning and implementation stages.
Transparency International Kenya maintained that major infrastructure investments should be subjected to proper scrutiny before public funds are committed.
The organisation’s executive director, Sheila Masinde, emphasised that development projects must be accompanied by fiscal discipline and accountability, particularly when they are financed using borrowed money that taxpayers are ultimately expected to repay.
The SGR’s financial challenges have become a significant concern for the government, especially as Kenya faces competing demands for public resources.
Revenue generated from passenger and freight services has been used to support loan repayments, while the National Treasury has also had to intervene in meeting financial obligations associated with the railway.
Kenya has previously restructured its Chinese loans, extending the repayment period to 2040 as part of efforts to ease pressure on government finances.
The government has also been pursuing plans to extend the railway from Naivasha towards Kisumu and Malaba, with a different financing arrangement.
However, the questions raised by the World Bank and Transparency International have placed renewed emphasis on the need for greater transparency in future infrastructure projects.
The SGR remains an important transport investment, connecting the Port of Mombasa to inland destinations and supporting passenger and cargo movement.
Nevertheless, its construction history offers important lessons about public procurement, project evaluation and the management of national debt.
As Kenya considers further railway expansion, the challenge will be ensuring that future investments deliver value for money while protecting public resources from waste, inflated costs and corruption risks.
THETRENDINGDESK feedback-opera-news-app@opera.com
Reported by News Hub Creator.
Read Original Report at news hub creator ↗
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share your opinion!