Convicted lawyer Andy Allman serving 35 years, but victims say their nightmare continues

Convicted lawyer Andy Allman serving 35 years, but victims say their nightmare continues

WatchArmstrong Williams Town HallArmstrong Williams takes on the news of the week and asks the questions you want answered. Don’t miss our weekly town hall.

3VIEW ALL PHOTOSDisbarred Tennessee attorney Andy Allman, pictured here, is serving 35 years for theft tied to 100 clients and $1.2M. (Photo: FOX 17 News)Comment on this story0CommentShare storySharetopics: Andy AllmanSumner CountyTennesseeParoleDisbarredTheftVictimsRestitutionNASHVILLE, Tenn. (WZTV) — More than 100 victims. More than $1.2 million in missing money. An attorney disbarred, disgraced and sentenced to 35 years in prison.

You might think that would be the end of the Andy Allman story.

Nearly a decade after FOX 17 News began investigating the Sumner County lawyer, some of his victims are still suffering. And in one particularly troubling case, Allman is continuing to pursue a former client in court — from behind prison walls.

You would think a convicted lawyer with no law license and no apparent source of income couldn't cause much more trouble.

But Andy Allman is still causing nightmares.

The FOX 17 News Ferrier Files investigation into Allman began nearly 10 years ago. There were so many complaints and alleged victims that determining the full extent of his wrongdoing was a monumental task.

The Tennessee Board of Professional Responsibility was conducting its own investigation.

Ultimately, disciplinary investigators determined Allman owed approximately $1.2 million to around 100 clients whose money he had taken or whose legal matters he had failed to handle.

Not every allegation resulted in criminal charges, but prosecutors built a substantial case.

Allman was convicted in Sumner County on 18 counts involving theft and impersonating a lawyer and sentenced to 35 years in prison.

"It's the longest trial I've ever had. We had over a hundred exhibits. We had nine days of testimony," said District Attorney General Thomas Dean, who prosecuted Allman.

Dean says that despite the overwhelming evidence, Allman never accepted responsibility for his actions.

"I've never seen him take responsibility. He will admit that he owes some money. He goes that far. But at the trial it was a cavalcade of excuses and blame on other people."

Dean says Allman repeatedly blamed employees and his bookkeeper for the missing money.

"We put on many bank representatives to make it clear who was making the financial decisions, who was moving the money, and that was Andy Allman," Dean said.

Allman was also convicted in Davidson County of stealing approximately $230,000 from the family of Baylor Bramble, a high school football player who suffered a traumatic brain injury.

The money was intended to help provide care for the injured young man.

"That young man passed away without any hope of what that care might have provided or maybe changed an outcome," Dean said.

Authorities recovered some money from Allman's accounts, and the Board of Professional Responsibility helped provide restitution to some victims.

But the amount recovered fell far short of the estimated $1.2 million in losses.

Many victims never recovered their money. Others lost something that couldn't be replaced: their opportunity to pursue a legal claim.

"You can't quantify that," Dean said.

"I'm sure there were some clients that he promised returns for. And just got them to give him a retainer, maybe they didn't have a good claim, others with good claims but none of them will ever know because they're not the sort of people who can just cut another check for $4,500 to some new attorney to get a do-over."

One of those clients was Linda Cela, a former civil servant who paid Allman $4,500 to represent her in an employment dispute.

According to Cela, Allman never filed her case, and the deadline to pursue her claim expired.

"I found out that he cashed my check the next day to pay his employees," Cela said.

Cela sued Allman in an attempt to recover her money.

What happened next is difficult to believe.

The disbarred attorney produced his own timesheet, claiming he had performed numerous hours of legal work for Cela and was actually owed approximately $10,000 in damages.

This despite courts previously rejecting Allman's timesheets and pointing to a lack of evidence that he performed the work he claimed.

Now, after years of legal battles and serious health problems, Cela has dropped her lawsuit.

But Allman's legal action against her has continued.

"I think he's harassing her," said her daughter, Tracy Cela "It's been 14 years, and she has been through three, four different surgeries and she's just not able to handle this anymore."

The family says Cela is exhausted, physically and emotionally, by the ordeal.

"We just want out, we just want to be left alone so that she can live out her last days as peaceful as possible."

For a woman who originally sought legal help, the experience has become a yearslong nightmare.

And even with Allman serving a lengthy prison sentence, she has struggled to escape it.

He challenged that decision, arguing that he posed no risk if released back into society.

District Attorney General Thomas Dean strongly disagrees.

Dean points to Allman's long history of continuing his behavior even as complaints, investigations and criminal charges mounted.

"When he started getting in trouble with the Board of Professional Responsibility, it did not change his behavior," Dean said.

"When we indicted him, it did not change his behavior. When they suspended him, it did not change his behavior."

Dean believes the record speaks for itself.

"So I think the record's pretty clear that the only way to keep Mr. Allman from trying to flimflam people is to have him locked up."

Allman's next parole hearing is scheduled for 2029.

But for Linda Cela, the prison walls haven't provided much protection.

The man she once hired to help her with a legal problem is still pursuing her in court, years after losing his law license and being convicted of stealing from clients.

Andy Allman may be locked up, but for at least one of his victims, he is still free to cause grief.

📰 Original Source Attribution

Reported by fox17.com.

Read Original Report at fox17.com ↗
Share: WhatsApp WhatsApp
💬

Comments (0)

Join the Conversation

No comments yet. Be the first to share your opinion!

You may like