Baton Rouge grandmother convicted of making 4-year-old drink herself to death seeks new trial

Baton Rouge grandmother convicted of making 4-year-old drink herself to death seeks new trial

A Baton Rouge woman who was found guilty of manslaughter after she forced her 4-year-old granddaughter to drink herself to death as punishment for taking a sip of whisky is seeking a new trial.

Attorneys for Roxanne Record, 57, argue that despite testimony from one of the victim’s siblings pointing to the alcohol poisoning being accidental, the jury was not given negligent homicide as an option when convicting her.

China Record died on April 21, 2022, at her home on Wallis Street.

In Judge Carson Marcantel’s court on Monday, defense attorney Caitlin Fowlkes argued for a new trial, an acquittal from the manslaughter charge, and a minimum sentence for Record should those motions fail.

“The state’s theory was that Miss Record forced China to drink a large amount of alcohol, which ultimately resulted in her death by intoxication. That was the state’s theory. The evidence produced at trial fell far short of establishing any such thing. In fact, the only evidence that was introduced at trial was that this child died of alcohol poisoning,” Fowlkes said.

Record was found guilty in May and faces a minimum sentence of 10 years in prison for the manslaughter conviction, because the victim was under 10. She could receive a maximum of 40 years in prison.

Marcantel is scheduled to rule on the new trial, acquittal and sentencing decisions on Dec. 4.

A Baton Rouge woman was found guilty of manslaughter Friday in the death of her 4-year-old granddaughter after making the child drink more tha…

Fowlkes said prosecutors originally indicted Record with first-degree murder, but jurors instead chose to find her guilty of the least-serious option available to them, manslaughter.

Fowlkes argued that jurors should have had the ability to convict Record of negligent homicide, since testimony from one of the victim’s siblings pointed to China taking the fatal amount of whisky by accident.

“The state produced evidence, produced testimony from one of the child witnesses, saying that China died as a result of getting into something she shouldn’t have gotten into, something she shouldn’t have gotten into at night while everyone was sleeping,” Fowlkes said.

Prosecutors argued at the time that there was no way China could have mistakenly consumed that amount of alcohol on her own, since that level of blood-alcohol content would have impaired even an adult’s ability to keep drinking.

The state’s forensic pathologist reported the girl had a 0.63% BAC at the time of her death.

This led Marcantel to disallow the lower charge of negligent homicide as an option for jurors.

Fowlkes argued, both in May and at court Monday, that the extent of a child’s poisoning does not prove that they were coerced into drinking any alcohol against their will.

Fowlkes also said that a court emotional-support dog, which accompanied one of China Record’s siblings on the stand as she testified, disrupted the trial and made itself visible to jurors. She argued this prejudiced the jury against Record.

Fowlkes also sought a new trial on the grounds that Marcantel made an “Allen charge” to jurors during the seven hours of deliberation they took before coming to a verdict. An Allen charge is an instruction from a judge for a jury to potentially reconsider their views if they are not able to come to a conclusion.

For the sentencing, Fowlkes requested the minimum punishment of 10 years for Record, saying in her motion that “a 10-year sentence will deprive her of a substantial portion of her remaining productive years and may, as a practical matter, consume the remainder of her natural life.”

She also argued that the jury’s choice of manslaughter over murder shows that a minimum punishment would be in line with their reading of the evidence.

Anna Kathryne Kronenberger, a local attorney whose children Record cared for as an employee of the Bocage Racquet Club, testified on Monday as a character witness.

Kronenberger sat in on the trial and said that rather than change her view, it actually cemented her belief in Record’s innocence. Kronenberger said she would still feel more than comfortable having Record watch her children.

The victim’s father, Emery Queen, also made a victim impact statement in court on Monday.

Queen did not directly condemn Record, saying that he did not know what actually happened leading up to his daughter’s death and had forgiven her before the trial even began.

“All I know is it happened,” Queen said. “I no longer have my sweetheart, and every day of my life I have to wake up and look at this portrait beside my bed and kiss the portrait.”

Kadjah Record, China’s mother, still faces her own charge of first-degree murder in the case. Her next hearing is scheduled for Dec. 15.

Email Quinn Coffman at quinn.coffman@theadvocate.com.

📰 Original Source Attribution

Reported by theadvocate.com.

Read Original Report at theadvocate.com ↗
Share: WhatsApp WhatsApp
💬

Comments (0)

Join the Conversation

No comments yet. Be the first to share your opinion!

You may like