WATCH: Keep asylum seekers out of cells
Share current article via FacebookShare current article via PinterestShare current article via WhatsAppShare current article via TwitterShare current article via LinkedInNewsWATCH: Keep asylum seekers out of cellsBy: Nhlanhla Khomola • 18m agoAdd as a preferred source on GoogleFollow on Google NewsListen to this article-00:00lead-art-block.fullscreen-enterExpandJoburg High Court Lawyers want undocumented immigrants released immediately to apply for asylum as court hears 33 applications in detention battle. (Nhlanhla Khomola) Lawyers argue detention violates asylum seekers’ rightsLAWYERS want undocumented foreigners released immediately to apply for asylum as the court hears 33 applications in detention battle.
Tap here to download the FREE Daily Sun App
Undocumented foreigners, who said they want asylum in South Africa, shouldn’t be kept behind bars while waiting for Home Affairs to process their applications.
This is the argument lawyers representing would-be asylum seekers put before the Gauteng High Court in Joburg on Monday, 16 November.
The court is hearing 33 applications following conflicting High Court rulings on the implementation of the Constitutional Court’s landmark Scalabrini judgment.
The previous judgment barred the state from deporting asylum seekers before their asylum claims had been assessed.
ALSO READ: Four foreign nationals, one big argument!
But judges have since disagreed on whether those who express an intention to seek asylum should be released from immigration detention or remain behind bars while Home Affairs facilitates the process.
Representing four of the applicants, Advocate Thato Madubanya argued that once a person expresses an intention to seek asylum, their circumstances should fall under the Refugees Act rather than the Immigration Act.
He said the Refugees Act must be read together with the Immigration Act and that an asylum claim must first be processed, even if the person is in the country unlawfully.
Madubanya referred to the Bula judgment, arguing that an asylum seeker’s expression of an intention to apply for asylum should trigger protection under the Refugees Act, even before a formal application has been lodged or considered.
He said the department could not rely on Section 34 of the Immigration Act to keep prospective asylum seekers in detention while trying to access the asylum application process.
“Once a person expresses an intention to apply, the Refugees Act must take over,” he argued.
Madubanya also told the court about an applicant whose legal battle for release had dragged on for weeks.
He said lawyers had consulted with the applicant before 9 September and launched an application seeking his release, as well as an opportunity to obtain the necessary documents to apply for asylum.
But the applicant remained in detention until 23 October, when he was eventually released with asylum documentation.
Madubanya argued that Home Affairs had known about the applicant’s intention to seek asylum since 10 September, a fact also acknowledged in the department’s court papers.
The applicant had also tried to approach Home Affairs in Lephalale to obtain the necessary documentation but had been unsuccessful.
Madubanya argued that the case showed why prospective asylum seekers should not be kept in detention while waiting for the department to help them access the asylum process.
He maintained that it should not matter whether a person was detained under Section 34 or Section 49 of the Immigration Act.
The lawyers want the court to make it clear that prospective asylum seekers should be released once they express an intention to apply for asylum, with Home Affairs then required to facilitate the process.
Passionate news journalist with a strong interest in investigative reporting, crime, courts, social justice and community news. Dedicated to uncovering the truth, Nhlanhla is committed to telling impactful stories that give a voice to ordinary people while holding those in positions of power accountable
Opens in new windowOpens in new windowOpens in new windowOpens in new windowOpens in new windowRelated ArticlesWATCH: Keep asylum seekers out of cells18m ago
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share your opinion!