Three sisters beat brother in bitter £1.6m inheritance fight over family fortune and £500k box of gold
Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in
Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Membership today.
Three sisters have beaten their “entitled” brother in a bitter £1.6m inheritance fight after claiming he wrongfully grabbed half their millionaire dad’s fortune for himself – including the family’s gold bars.
Hari Grover died, aged 85, without making a will in September 2024, leaving behind an estate in England valued for probate at around £865,000 -including his house in Ealing – plus a stash of gold bars and jewellery in a safety despite box in India worth up to £500,000.
His only son Sonny Grover was appointed administrator of his estate and – his sisters say – instructed to “look after” them by their dad on his death bed by splitting the family fortune equally.
But sisters, Airan Grover-Jones, Kiran Cotterell and Kelly Puri, ended up suing their brother, claiming that the value of their dad’s estate was far higher than the figure declared by Sonny.
They argued their dad’s estate in England was actually worth around £1.15m, their brother having wrongly claimed to be the joint owner of their father’s £300,000 life savings and to have been given the gold and jewellery in the box.
Their lawyers accused him of having “misappropriated money and the other property” belonging to the estate by having not included hundreds of thousand of pounds worth of assets to be shared with his sisters.
But representing himself, Sonny insisted that the money in his dad’s account had passed directly to him as he had been made a joint “beneficial holder” years before he died, while the box of gold and jewellery had also been gifted to him.
Giving his ruling, Judge Nicholas Parfitt slammed Sonny for being “constantly argumentative” in court and declared that the £300,000 in his dad’s bank account belonged to the estate not him and so would be split with his sisters.
He also ruled that Sonny had not been “gifted” the contents of the safety deposit box as he believed, but rather that he had been “entrusted” to hold it in trust for the family as a whole.
He said Sonny, who lived with his father in his last years, had felt that “he and his wife had acted like angels towards his father” and had developed “a sense of entitlement, a sense of preference, a sense of desert” as a result.
Handing him his sisters’ £80,000 legal bill for the row, the judge declined their bid to immediately remove him as estate administrator, instead allowing him six more months in the hope that any further issues can be agreed by the family, telling the warring siblings to “put their big person pants on and get it sorted out.”
The row at Mayors and City County Court revolved around how much of his fortune was included in Hari Grover’s estate to be shared equally by his children on his death, with Sonny claiming it amounted to £865,000.
His sisters said it was much more because it should have included the £300,000 “life savings” in the bank account, while also disputing Sonny’s claim that he had been given the contents of the safety deposit box, which they insisted was family property and contained some items gifted specifically to them.
Representing himself, Sonny claimed that his dad’s savings account had “passed to him by survivorship” because his father had “attended a branch and executed a formal mandate” making him a joint holder of the account eight years before his death.
He also said he believed that the gold and jewellery in the safety deposit box had been “gifted” to him by his dad, along with control of the lock-up itself in 2017.
Giving his ruling, the judge said that after Hari’s death the family had initially got on but “began to disagree and fell out” when it came to filling out inheritance tax forms, and Sonny subsequently took “unilateral” steps to deal with the estate, which deepened the rift.
“Sonny was an extremely poor witness because he was simply constantly argumentative,” he said.
“He is essentially seeing this case as an argument between him and his sisters and as long as he can keep swinging he is in the game.
“Unfortunately that is not the way the court makes decisions. It seeks to establish what the facts are from the documents that are made available and the recollections of the witnesses.”
He added that there was “no criticism of the work done [by Sonny] on the estate outside of the relevant items…he has done a good job”.
But he said Sonny “believes that a just result in this case is one which would see him getting everything and his sisters getting nothing, because that’s what he deserves”.
Addressing Sonny’s belief that his dad’s savings account was a joint account that passed to him automatically on his father’s death, that he had put some money into it himself, and that the bank had told him it didn’t need to be included in the estate, the judge said: “It is the court, not the bank, that decides this dispute, surprisingly enough.
“I’m not persuaded that any part of the funds in the account at the date of death had been sourced from Sonny’s assets.
“This is the account in which his father’s life savings were held,” said the judge, adding that he had heard evidence that Hari kept his pass book to the account “secret” and wrapped up hidden in his clothes.
“That is indicative that the father kept this account to himself. I don’t think he involved Sonny at all,” he concluded, ruling that Sonny was not a “beneficial” joint holder of the account at the time Hari died.
Turning to the box of gold, the judge said that “what [Hari] said to his daughters when he was facing death was ‘don’t worry you can trust your brother, he will share things equally’.”
That statement indicated that whilst he had signed over control of the box to Sonny in 2017, Hari had not meant for him to own everything in it, the judge said.
He said there was “uncertainty about the contents of the box” and ruled that Hari had “entrusted the box to [Sonny] rather than gifted it.
“I don’t think it would be right to declare that the contents of the box belongs to the estate, but that Sonny and his wife held the contents on trust,” he said, declaring that “an account” must now be given by Sonny of the contents of the box when he was handed control of it in 2017.
The judge delayed a decision on whether to replace Sonny as administrator for six months, in order to give “final opportunity for the parties to cooperate.”
“It does seem to me that the family needs to decide whether the family [gold] collection should be broken up and distributed to this generation or that certain items should be taken out by those who own them,” he said.
“They need to put their big person pants on and get it sorted out.”
Sonny was left in place as administrator of the estate for six months, under the condition that he takes no “unilateral” decisions about assets and notifies his sisters before making any move, as well as complying with the court’s orders.
The judge also ordered that Sonny is responsible for paying his sisters’ costs of the court case, estimated at £80,000, out of his share of the estate.
An application for a payment on account of costs was stayed for six months.
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies
Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in
Reported by independent.co.uk.
Read Original Report at independent.co.uk ↗
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share your opinion!