Three Major Problems Cited For Manchester United’s Struggles
Monday, November 16, 2026 Login Top StoriesNewsGeneral NewsEducationHealthOpinionsEconomicsEconomyFinanceBankingInsurancePensionSecurities/MarketsBusinessAgribusinessVaultz BusinessExtractives/EnergyReal EstateWorldAfricaAmericaEuropeUKUSAAsiaAround the GlobeInnovationTechnologyWheelsEntertainment20MOBPL2DNewJobs & ScholarshipsJob VacanciesScholarships No Result View All Result Top StoriesNewsGeneral NewsEducationHealthOpinionsEconomicsEconomyFinanceBankingInsurancePensionSecurities/MarketsBusinessAgribusinessVaultz BusinessExtractives/EnergyReal EstateWorldAfricaAmericaEuropeUKUSAAsiaAround the GlobeInnovationTechnologyWheelsEntertainment20MOBPL2DNewJobs & ScholarshipsJob VacanciesScholarships No Result View All Result No Result View All Result in Sports Three Major Problems Cited For Manchester United’s Strugglesby Frank Odoi Asare November 16, 2026 Reading Time: 6 mins read Add as Preferred on Google Manchester United’s decision to part ways with Michael Carrick has brought renewed focus to the problems undermining the club’s performances, with Ghanaian sports journalist and analyst Nathan Quao identifying weaknesses in recruitment, player fitness and coaching as major factors behind their disappointing campaign.
Carrick was relieved of his duties on November 12, less than six months after securing a permanent appointment, following a difficult start to the 2026/27 season that left the Red Devils struggling in the Premier League relegation zone. The club’s decision to appoint Mauricio Pochettino, who is expected to take charge on November 18, represents another attempt to restore stability at Old Trafford.
Quao, who examined United’s difficulties during a discussion with The Vaultz News, believes the club’s problems extend beyond the performances of individual players, pointing to three interconnected issues that have made it increasingly difficult for the team to compete.
“There are a couple of issues facing the club. One, a fitness problem. A player quality problem, a coaching problem. So, if you put all of that together, you are saying a team that is struggling, a team that can’t compete, because they didn’t improve their team. They had a very poor pre-season, which physically didn’t prepare them for the campaign. And they were being coached badly.”
His assessment highlights the broader challenges facing United, suggesting that replacing the head coach alone may not be sufficient to address the problems that have contributed to their disappointing campaign.
Quao believes United entered the season with several identifiable weaknesses in their squad but failed to address enough of them during the transfer window.
While strengthening the midfield was considered a major priority, he argued that the club should have paid greater attention to other positions that required immediate improvement.
The left-back position was among his biggest concerns, with United also needing additional quality at centre-back and another striker to provide support for Benjamin Sesko.
According to Quao, the failure to strengthen those areas left the squad vulnerable, particularly when injuries and inconsistent performances began affecting the team’s ability to compete. “Even though the plan was that United should fix the midfield, I think there were other problem areas United could have looked at to try and manage to bring in a player or two in those areas to help,” he explained.
He placed responsibility for the recruitment shortcomings on the club’s ownership and football management structure, particularly the INEOS leadership under Sir Jim Ratcliffe.
The analyst also questioned whether United had done enough to create the necessary competition within the squad, arguing that quality reinforcements could have provided Carrick with “better options” when attempting to manage difficult situations during matches.
His argument suggests that United’s struggles cannot be attributed exclusively to the head coach, especially when shortcomings in squad construction had already left several positions requiring attention.
Beyond recruitment, Quao identified inadequate physical preparation as another significant factor behind United’s poor performances.
He argued that the club’s pre-season preparations failed to provide the players with the necessary fitness levels to sustain their performances throughout the campaign, leaving them struggling to cope with the demands of competitive football.
Also , he questioned Carrick’s tactical approach during his reign, pointing to poor execution of game plans and the team’s inability to respond effectively to different challenges during matches.
He referenced United’s defeat to Bournemouth as an example of the coaching shortcomings, arguing that the team’s approach and execution raised questions about the quality of its preparation.
Quao also highlighted the difficulty United had in managing defensive situations, particularly when individual mistakes began affecting players’ confidence.
He cited Leny Yoro as an example, observing that the young defender’s confidence appeared to deteriorate whenever he committed an error, making it increasingly difficult for him to recover during matches.
The problem, in his assessment, was not simply the occurrence of individual mistakes but the team’s inability to manage those situations and prevent them from developing into further problems.
He also questioned the predictability of United’s tactical approach, suggesting that opponents had found it relatively easy to identify and exploit weaknesses in their game.
For Quao, these concerns reinforced the need to examine the coaching structure alongside the quality of the playing personnel.
His assessment also provides context to Carrick’s departure, with United’s hierarchy ultimately deciding that a managerial change was necessary after the team’s disappointing start to the campaign.
With Carrick gone, Pochettino faces the difficult task of addressing the problems that have undermined United’s season and restoring the club’s competitiveness.
The former Tottenham Hotspur and Chelsea manager arrives with considerable Premier League experience, having previously established himself as one of the division’s prominent coaches through his work at Southampton and Tottenham.
His appointment offers United an opportunity to introduce a different tactical direction, but Quao’s assessment suggests that the new manager will need more than “tactical adjustments” to turn the situation around.
The Argentine will inherit a squad with identifiable weaknesses, fitness concerns and a need for greater consistency in executing tactical instructions.
Addressing those issues will require cooperation between the coaching staff, those responsible for recruitment and the club’s hierarchy, particularly as United seek to rebuild a team capable of challenging for major honours again.
Carrick’s dismissal may have provided the club with an opportunity to change direction, but the underlying problems identified by Quao remain important considerations for his successor.
Ultimately, Pochettino’s success will depend not only on his ability to improve performances on the pitch but also on whether United can address the recruitment and structural shortcomings that have repeatedly undermined their progress.
The managerial change has created a fresh beginning at Old Trafford, but rebuilding Manchester United will require a more comprehensive solution than simply changing the man in the dugout.
Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.
Reported by thevaultznews.com.
Read Original Report at thevaultznews.com ↗
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share your opinion!