“Release Them or Keep Them Locked Up?” Joburg High Court Decides Fate of 33 Asylum Seekers
The High Court in Johannesburg is set to continue important hearings this week on the detention of people who want to apply for asylum in South Africa. The full court, made up of more than one judge, is looking at 33 urgent cases involving undocumented foreign nationals who say they intend to seek asylum. These hearings, running from Monday to Wednesday, follow a major Constitutional Court decision earlier this year that struck down parts of the Refugee Act as unconstitutional and invalid.
In July 2026, the Constitutional Court confirmed that certain sections of the Refugees Act could no longer stand. Those sections had made it hard for people who entered the country without proper papers or a transit visa to even start the asylum process. The court ruled that officials cannot simply turn people away or detain them without first looking at the actual reasons why they are seeking protection. This is based on the principle that no one should be sent back to a place where they may face harm or persecution. The ruling has created different approaches in the lower courts about what should happen when someone says they want to apply for asylum but is already in detention.
Judges in various divisions have not always agreed on whether such people must be released while their claims are checked, or whether they can stay locked up. The Johannesburg High Court has now brought the cases together under a full bench so that one clear approach can be set for the whole country. This is meant to bring legal certainty and make sure the same rules are followed everywhere. Five friends of the court and two other parties have been allowed to take part and present their views on the constitutional issues involved.
The matter was originally scheduled for late October but was postponed because more parties joined and more arguments were filed. Home Affairs and immigration officials have faced practical challenges since the Constitutional Court decision, including long queues at refugee offices and questions about how to handle people who come forward after being arrested. Civil society groups and legal organisations have argued that detaining someone before their asylum claim is properly assessed goes against the spirit of the ruling and South Africa’s international obligations.
For the people involved in the 33 applications, the outcome could decide whether they remain in detention or are released while their cases are processed. For the Department of Home Affairs, the judgment will guide how officers treat prospective asylum seekers in future. For the broader public, the hearings will clarify how South Africa balances border control with the rights of those who claim they need protection.
As the three-day hearing begins, legal experts say the court’s decision is likely to shape immigration practice for years to come. Clear rules on detention will help both officials and applicants understand their rights and responsibilities under the law. The full bench is expected to deliver guidance that brings more consistency to how these sensitive cases are handled across the country.
Source: https://x.com/SABCNews/status/2122179995959255374?a=fRqvmb_Ufaj60amcTQA&s=19
Jackson feedback-opera-news-app@opera.com
Reported by News Hub Creator.
Read Original Report at news hub creator ↗
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share your opinion!