Ramaphosa to hire mediators to resolve power clashes between ministers and DGs

Ramaphosa to hire mediators to resolve power clashes between ministers and DGs

Share current article via EmailShare current article via FacebookShare current article via TwitterShare current article via LinkedInKabelo KhumaloDeputy Editor

Opens in new windowOpens in new windowEnter fullscreen mode displaying this image.ExpandPresident Cyril Ramaphosa turns to independent mediation amid allegations of sabotage in national departments. Picture: Supplied Story audio is generated using AI

Amid growing claims by ministers that they are being sabotaged by senior government officials in their departments, President Cyril Ramaphosa has turned to independent mediators to resolve their squabbles which, at times, bring service delivery to a halt.

Reports of conflicts between ministers and directors-general (DGs) are on the rise, with the DA recently claiming its ministers in the government of national unity (GNU) were sabotaged by officials.

During the formation of the GNU, the DA demanded a direct say in selecting directors-general in national departments assigned to DA ministers, alongside the review of existing directors-general contracts.

This was turned down by the president who argued that the appointment of directors-general was constitutionally and legally vested in him under the Public Service Act.

To avoid accusations of bias in resolving disputes, the president has resorted to appointing an independent mediator to assist him in dealing with the weighty matters that come before him.

The appointment will be done through an open tender process, with the terms of reference of facilitating the resolution of “disputes, disagreements, relationship breakdowns or any similar matter that may arise” between ministers and directors-general, according to the tender document published by the presidency.

South Africa has a long history of ministers clashing with director generals — the de facto CEOs of the departments.

The most recent was the public spat between minister of basic education Siviwe Gwarube and director-general Mathanzima Mweli after the latter refused to undergo a lifestyle audit by the Special Investigating Unit (SIU), citing constitutional rights to privacy and arguing the process lacks specific legislation.

Gwarube insisted because the director-general oversees billions of rand in public procurement, submitting to an SIU lifestyle audit is essential for accountability.

Minister of higher education and training Buti Manamela and the department’s administrative head, Nkosinathi Sishi, reportedly clashed over departmental decisions made since the minister assumed office earlier this year.

The DA, the second-largest party in the GNU, has publicly alleged that its ministers in government face internal resistance, leaks and political sabotage as they attempt to reform mismanaged and neglected state institutions.

The president by law is clothed with the powers to appoint directors-general and make decisions regarding their career incidents in national departments.

However, managing conflict between ministers and their directors-general has become a fraught exercise for Ramaphosa since the advent of the GNU, which has seen several cabinet members drawn from outside the ranks of the ANC — many of whom inherited directors-general from ANC ministers.

“Now and then the president is required to intervene to resolve disputes between executive authorities and their heads of department (HODs),” the terms of reference in the tender document read.

“Previous experience shows that disputes/breakdowns in the working relationship between executive authorities and HODs affect service delivery and sometimes end up in protracted labour disputes and/or litigation wherein the president, as the appointing authority, would be required to intervene.”

“The presidency desires to build internal capacity to handle these matters as per the law. The current practice of dealing with disputes between executive authorities and HODs is protracted and sometimes costly, as it will require delegations from the president to the deputy president or a minister to be followed. Government programme continuity and delivery unavoidably get interrupted.”

South Africa’s laws give ministers the authority to set strategic policy direction, while directors-general are responsible for executing plans within legal and fiscal frameworks. However, in practice these boundaries often blur, leading to political interference in administrative decisions and service delivery failures follow.

The president in April signed into law the Public Service Amendment Act and the Public Administration Management Amendment Act — fundamentally reshaping the powers of directors-general and HODs. These laws aim to professionalise the public service by creating a clear legal separation between political leadership and administrative management.

While ministers retain the power to set strategic and political direction as the executive authority, directors-general and employees reporting directly to them are now prohibited from holding office in a political party.

More significantly, directors-general and HODs are now responsible for recruitment and other human resource matters in their depart­ments. This authority was previously vested in ministers and MECs.

The presidency said the mediation process is intended to promote effective governance, professional working relationships, accountability, and the uninterrupted delivery and or continuity of government programmes and services.

“While parties may be directed by the president to participate in a mediation process, any settlement or agreement reached shall be voluntary and based on informed consent.”

Would you like to comment on this article?Sign up (it's quick and free) or sign in now.

Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.

📰 Original Source Attribution

Reported by businessday.co.za.

Read Original Report at businessday.co.za ↗
Share: WhatsApp WhatsApp
💬

Comments (0)

Join the Conversation

No comments yet. Be the first to share your opinion!

You may like