Manchester United must release three ‘toxic’ players and ‘take medicine’ in Arsenal-inspired plan
Manchester United duo Bruno Fernandes and Lisandro Martinez Mauricio Pochettino and Manchester United might as well copy Arsenal’s five-phase plan, so successfully did Mikel Arteta see that through.
Send your thoughts to theeditor@football365.com.
They will never recover There is an underlying notion among Manchester United fans that there will be, at some point in the future, a club and team rising from the ashes, competing for the Premier League title and even the Champions League.
No manager will be able to produce a title winning team. It will be too expensive. People talk about needing a new defender or attacker, but not one of the current team is good enough. Sure, you can name a few who might be okay, but then compare to the players of the recent past. Ruud, Beckham, Giggs, Neville, Schmeichel, Keane, Scholes, Ronaldo, Rooney…etc etc…
Not one of the team going out for the next game could light a candle to them.
And the owners are not interested. The Glazers have said it, they don’t need to win anything, the power of the brand keeps the dosh piling in, so why spend the £500million or more. (A conservative estimate)
As for Ratcliffe, he has shown himself to be about as adept at running a football club as I would be! His hubris resulting from building a polluting petrochemical business makes him think he knows more about football than any other punter. He doesn’t. And he won’t listen because he knows best. In fact. I think I do know more, as I had a great chat with Gary McAlliter once that left me knowing I knew nothing (a bit of Socrates there).
As for the directors involved in the recruitment of managers, why are they still there? Surely they have a performance element to their contracts?
So it is a lost cause. It’s over. And United fans in the future will be like Wolves fans who started supporting them in the late ’50s and werestuck with a lifetime of hope that turned to despair. Tim
It might be alright The problem with Poch is not that he won’t turn this around in the long term, he’s generally done that everywhere he’s been. In time he will leave Manchester United better off than 18th. The football will be better, the players will be fitter, the fans happier.
The problem is that he starts slowly everywhere he goes and United are in a relegation battle. He’s going to have turn the ship around faster than he usually does or he will be managing in the Championship next season.
Will he get the time and the players to do it?
And to those saying Carrick had to be hired in the summer: a competent and ruthless leadership would have known what was coming and moved Carrick on. City did this with Pellegrini when they knew Pep was available. The real problem for United was the World Cup. Well, that and they didn’t have the guts or intelligence to make the right calls. Ashmundo
Objectives: Set the culture / non-negotiables / the fogging standards. Raise the floor, get rid of the problem/old/overpaid players. Get back into Europe/CL.
Season 20-21 (Finished 8th) Played pretty turgid 343, setting patterns and standards.
Transfers In: Partey, Gabriel, Odegaard, Pablo Mari, Willian, Cedric – Fair to say that was hit and miss! But 2 bangers in there.
Out: Emi, Guendouzi, Mkhi, Mustafi, Ozil, Sokratis – some very bad, very annoying, very overpaid players there that needed to leave.
Season 21-22 (5th) Played decent football, pipped at the post for CL.
In: Ben White, Ramsdale, Tomi, Lakonga, Tavares – mixed window, White and Ramsdale both go onto to have great seasons
Out: Willock, Auba, Callum Chambers, Willian, David Luiz, Kolasinac – more overpaid and over the hill players out the door, many left on a free but you have to take your medicine. Bold move getting rid of your top goalscorer.
For Utd, this would involve getting rid of the likes Bruno, Maguire, Martinez et al. They are toxic. Get young hungry players in the 22 – 25 age range who want to be there.
Objectives: Introduce winning mentality. Raise the ceiling, continue to get rid of the players that are not good enough. Get back into CL.
Season 22-23 (2nd) Surprise title challenge, played great football, got done by City juggernaut
In: Jesus, Zinny, Vieira, Leo, Kiwior, Jorginho – decent window, clearly going for winning mentality
Out: Leno, Mavrapanos, Hector, Laca, Pepe – more overpaid players who are clearly not good enough allowed to leave, again very little in transfer fees but better just to get rid
For Utd, carry on getting rid of all the guff players, for nothing if necessary, bring in some winners top 6 sides who can’t get a game but are willing to join Utd. This may feel dirty but that’s where you are in the process.
Objectives: Raise the ceiling again, money no object. Start recycling squad players. Challenge for the title. Try to address issue of running out of legs the previous season.
Season 23-24 (2nd again) Played more great football, got 89 points, done by City on last day
In: Dec, Kai, Timber, Raya – all timer of a window
Out: Balogun, Xhaka, Mari, Tierney, AMN – all a bit meh
This is when Utd can go big again, compete for best players in the league.
Objectives: Win the bloody thing FFS! Have a good go at the CL.
Season 24-25 (2nd again, ole, ole) A season to forget, turgid football, lots of injuries, lots of red cards
In: Cala, Merino – Quiet window, recouping some of the large outlay the previous summer, already upgrading (a theme under Mik, see also goalies) LB from 2 summers ago, if you’re not good enough, good bye
Out: ESR, Eddie, Ramsdale – 2 academy grads and former team of the season goalie, showing Miks ruthlessness
For Utd, time to be ruthless! Doesn’t matter if they are academy players like Mainoo, if they are not good enough, get rid!
Objectives: Time to dominate, the winning window is open. Raise the floor again, no bums. Win the Prem, try and win the CL. Address issue of injuries from previous season.
Season 25-26 (1st) After 22 years finally won, more turgid football, no reds!
In: Zubi, Vic, Eze, Noni, Hincapie, Mosquera, Kepa – clearly filling out the squad to ensure a challenge on all fronts
Out: Partey, Tierney, Zinny, Jorginho, Kiwior, Tavares – getting rid of squad players from previous phases that have been upgraded
Season 26-27 (?) Overwhelming favourites to do it again
In: Bruno, Konsa, Tsolis – Win now players
Out: Martinelli, Tross, Jesus, Vieira – clearing the decks for the elite attacker that never arrived
For Utd this would mean fleshing out the squad with oven ready players.
As we know every club is different and has different challenges, Utd more than most. And the one thing that you definitely need is everyone pulling in the same direction from owner to execs, to managers and coaches, to players and fans.
Although the blame at Utd is often placed at the execs doors, Mik has worked under Raul, Edu, Berta and others during his tenure. I do believe managing up is a massively underrated quality for coaches at top clubs that Mik clearly has in abundance.
You also have to be ruthless along the way. In initial phases getting rid of stalwarts and club favourites that can no longer cut it is difficult but has to be done, that includes players with the right ability but not the right character, I’m looking at you Bruno! You have to be ruthless in the middle phases, again possibly getting rid of youth players that fans love, or purchases from earlier phases, such as Ramsdale and Zinny at Arsenal.
A club shouldn’t be afraid to recycle players too, a player good enough for phase 3 may not be good enough for phase 5. Even some of the players Arsenal bought last summer, such as Vic and Zubi are already deemed not good enough and can’t get a game. It’s that ruthless mentality that continues to drive the club forward. As you can see Arsenal were often a season or 2 away from where they wanted to be but they stuck with it and dear I say it they trusted the process and now they are reaping the rewards.
Is Poch the man for the job at Utd? Time will tell if he has the ability, authority and ruthlessness to make it happen. AB Maidenhead
I pity the fool Muthama Gitonga, Nairobi Kenya, raises an interesting point about whether we should stop laughing at Utd.
Personally I’d rather be mocked than pitied. Mockery is sht, but at least indicates relevance, reflects former glory and a fear it will one day return.
Was at school and uni during Utd’s pomp, took a lot of sh*t from their fans, and know in my bones they’ll be back before long…so I’ll continue laughing for now. Aidan, Lfc (being forgotten would be the worst of all)
The Glazers A lot has been written about the Glaziers, but I can’t recall seeing anything about the impact of all their financial chicanery in one place. So, with the help of Gemini AI, here goes.
Back in 2005 they bought Utd for around £790M, contributing about £270M of their own money. The £520M as everyone knows was loaded onto a debt-free club. This debt has cost the club over £1 billion on interest and financing fees, and whoever ultimately buys the shares of the club gets this debt to sort out as well.
In addition to this they have extracted over £200k on dividends management fees. They also trousered around £1.3B for selling some of their shares to Sir Ineos.
On the plus side they have seen an increase in turnover from around £180M to over £650M in recent years. Sounds impressive doesn’t it? But not when you take into account what other Premiership clubs achieved during the same period. In the early 2000s, Utd were regularly #1 in revenue globally, but have now slipped down to 8th, surpassed by teams like City and Liverpool.
During the Glaziers ownership net investment in the team is around £1b. On a par with the likes of City and Chelsea, but whereas their cash for this spend came from owner investment, Utd’s spend was entirely self generated.
So, for an initial investment of £270M, they so far have had a return of around £1.5b whilst maintaining ownership of shares currently valued around £3.5b. Assuming they get this when they sell they will get a return of £5b, a net return of 1752%, leaving behind a £1b debt for running the club into the ground.
The one time any of the muppets the Glazer family have delegated picking a manager to make the right choice (Eddie Howe), the Glazer family overule them and pick another muppet (MoPo). You couldnt make this sh*t up.
The only good news for united fans is that this could be the last disaster the Glazers preside over. They cant keep on pounding MUFC into the ground forever, can they? Surely MoPo’s ship steadying mediocrity will finally herald the end of the Glazer era????? Ben
The myth of the super rich Dearest Mailbox,
The Glazers and Jim Rat’s Chuff haven’t done much at United so far that could be described as ‘best in class’, I think most people would agree with that. What they have done well, as a result, is to highlight to anyone with any level of interest in football that the super-rich are not quite the pioneering brainboxes we’re led to believe.
When I say ‘led to believe’ – there’s a lot of leading to believe around. The media endlessly describing billionaires as ‘job creators’. The phrase ‘angel investors’ gets touted around too. The prolonged lauding of Mr Elongated Muskrat as some sort of Iron Man genius from the future.
The reasons behind this are pretty obvious – the super-rich want to convince people that they’re vastly superior beings to the rest of us, and that they therefore deserve to drain all the money from society rather than being taxed properly. To fix the economy by taxing them a small proportion of their enormous wealth is to resort to that favourite line of political commentators and other paid stooges, ‘the politics of envy’. They are geniuses, and they deserve to wake up every morning hundreds of thousands of pounds better off, having (remarkably) done no work while asleep.
The incompetence and greed displayed by the Glazers and Jim has gone a long way to undermining this particular propaganda campaign, and I am totally here for it. For a start, the business model: load up a successful business with debt to avoid any personal risk, then get Jim in to make mass redundancies. Doesn’t exactly scream ‘job creator’, that, does it? Of course, the idea that billionaires are ‘job creators’ relies on the assumption that had, say, Amazon not been established, then nobody would now be buying or selling consumer goods, or working in that sector. But that’s it – they’re not creating new jobs, they’re replacing independent businesses with roles that offer less job security, less pay, and worse conditions. And in the case of all the tea ladies at Old Trafford, those roles aren’t even being replaced.
‘Angel investors’ – a phrase that suggests the super-wealthy are investing out of the goodness of their heart, to help start-ups reach their full potential. Nothing to do with the share of the profits in perpetuity, of course. The Glazers have demonstrated just how cancerous (I can say that, Stage 3 survivor (for now) over here) the wrong investors can be to any business, sucking out all the profits and running the place into the ground.
Manchester United over the last 20 years has been a high-profile example of what the super-rich can do to businesses and to society. While I’d prefer owners who are more competent and less vampiric, they are at least doing a good job at countering the nonsense peddled by the mass media. So that’s something. A left-back would be nice too.
PSA for Gunners I’ll keep it simple, and in list form for the hard of thinking:
1) I know 99% of Arsenal fans claim they don’t care about the sh*te Arteta serves up week after depressing week because you are winning, and champions/champions-elect. Fine, I’m pleased for you.
2) Re 1), then what the f**k are you all moaning at re my mails? Can’t have it both ways. Me, I’d just be saying, “yeah, we’re a horrible watch, but we’re champs”. The fact that so many of you rise to the bait tells me you absolutely are arsed how you play and what everyone else thinks of it.
3) I get that Gooner Central Social Media Narrative Command has issued you all with the, ‘we used to play ace and lose, now we play ugly and win’ crib sheet. Fine, but proper elite managers can do both. Many with significantly less resources than Arteta. I loved Wenger’s early Arsenal for example, because Wenger could attack AND defend AND win.
4) Bar other managers potentially being encouraged to copy Arteta’s approach, I couldn’t give a fuck who wins the prem really, and this next bit is the real crux for me: I just want to watch decent football. Writing mails about my displeasure that Arteta routinely fails to deliver this is just cathartic for me.
5) Finally, not a single one of you has been able to successfully address any of my actual points (bar trotting out 3), so you resort to insults. Which tells me I’m right and it grips your shit. RHT/TS x (From odious prick to a writer of moving messages in two mails, it’s almost like some things are more important than whether I like Arteta’s take on football or not, huh Stu? You have my full and genuine sympathies re your Mother though – cancer is a horrific illness)
England were exceptional in beating world champions Spain to win their Nations League group – but who let the team down in victory?
Why should fans bear the entire financial burden when fixtures are moved for commercial reasons? Some are left stranded following their team.
Manchester United boss Mauricio Pochettino is no stranger to Premier League management – nor some of his upcoming opponents in the dugout.
Manchester United must give Mauricio Pochettino time to properly embed his proven modern tactics on this embarrassing group of players.
Harry Kane will definitely turn his nose up at ‘volatile’ Spurs because it is easy to see where Manchester United will be in six months’ time.
Mauricio Pochettino worked wonders at Southampton and Spurs, and there is plenty of mitigation for struggling to get a tune out of Chelsea…
Reported by football365.com.
Read Original Report at football365.com ↗
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share your opinion!