Man found guilty in deputy’s death returns to court for sentencing
Download the FREE FOX19 NOW news app for iPhone
Download the FREE FOX19 NOW news app for Android
CINCINNATI (WXIX) – The man found guilty in the murder of a Hamilton County Sheriff’s Office deputy returns to court Monday morning for sentencing.
Rodney Hinton Jr. was found guilty of murder, reckless homicide and felonious assault for deliberately hitting and killing Hamilton County Deputy Larry Henderson on May 2, 2025.
The court is also expected to consider a motion his defense team filed Thursday seeking permission to subpoena jurors under seal.
“This is a problem, and you can’t do that. A juror must follow the law,” Clyde Bennett, Hinton’s attorney, said.
The problem, Attorney Clyde Bennett said, is that jurors improperly used statements Hinton made to psychologists to decide whether he was guilty at trial.
FULL COVERAGE | Rodney Hinton Jr. murder trial
Court records said the judge instructed jurors to consider those statements only when weighing his insanity defense.
Bennett said a juror told him that was not what happened at the conclusion of the trial.
“One juror expressed, stated in front of everybody in the room that we did discuss, and then my second question was, did you consider that in determining whether he was guilty of the offenses you found him guilty of? The offense that you found him guilty of, and she said yes and also expressed some concerns that they did it,” Bennett said.
Jurors convicted Hinton of murder, reckless homicide and felonious assault.
Bennett has requested a new trial following the verdict.
Prosecutors said sufficient evidence supports the verdicts and that jurors found Hinton “acted knowingly.” They also argue there is no legal basis for granting a new trial and are asking the judge to deny the motion.
“You are denied a fair trial if you utilize statements that a defendant makes to a psychologist in determining whether or not he’s guilty,” Bennett said.
If the verdict and trial stand, Hinton faces 15 years to life.
Do you have a photo or video of a breaking news story? Send it to us here with a brief description.
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share your opinion!