Is Rory McIlroy now Europe’s greatest ever golfer?
Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in
Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Membership today.
As recently as two years ago there was a feeling that Rory McIlroy might have peaked. It had been a decade since his previous major tournament victory – the 2014 PGA Championship – and the emergence of prolific American stars such as Scottie Scheffler seemed to suggest that McIlroy’s quest for another major title would go on indefinitely.
Then came 2025 and the pristinely manicured vistas of Augusta National. A dramatic play-off against fellow European great Justin Rose and the end of a lifelong pursuit to get his hands on The Masters trophy. With it also came the career grand slam and a place in the pantheon containing just five other men to achieve the feat, with McIlroy the only European on the list.
Only four golfers in history have won consecutive Masters titles and this year McIlroy joined that list as well by fully banishing his previous demons at Augusta to claim a second green jacket and emulate undisputed legends Jack Nicklaus, Tiger Woods and Sir Nick Faldo.
And now, at the age of 37, McIlroy looks to be solidly in the midst of a career renaissance and is more than delivering on the potential he showed as an 18-year-old debutant at the British Masters in 2007. Six major titles, six wins for Europe at the Ryder Cup, and, most recently, a record-equalling eighth European Tour Order of Merit crown with more accolades and titles seemingly on the horizon.
In the face of such evidence it is easy to throw out the claim that McIlroy is Europe’s greatest ever golfer but even he might deny himself that honour… for now.
And only for now because there is still a debate to be had over what makes someone great.
In terms of numbers and accolades, McIlroy is near the top of most lists. But near the top isn’t the same as being on top and this is something McIlroy is aware of.
Sunday’s final round at the DP World Tour Championship saw McIlroy battle it out with Spain’s Eugenio Chacarra in a topsy-turvy contest to see which player would claim the Race to Dubai title (the modern equivalent of the Order of Merit) and it was McIlroy, with a bogey-free round of 67, who clinched outright second place and enough ranking points to finish as the No.1 European golfer on tour for 2026.
That victory, also his fifth consecutive Race to Dubai title, drew him level with Colin Montgomerie on a record eight European Tour title victories and McIlroy has his sights on more.
“Yeah, double digits,” replied McIlroy when asked how many Race to Dubai victories he’s targeting following Sunday’s dramatic finale.
“I’d love to surpass Monty next year and we’ll go from there. Winning eight Order of Merits was never in my list of goals growing up.
“I remember Monty being a stalwart of the European tour and playing with him at the London Club in 2008, so to pull up alongside him and win eight of these means the world to me.”
Montgomerie’s record stood for 21 years and it was long believed that he would never be matched. Now McIlroy has designs to outdo him. Even as early as next year though an influx of former LIV Golf players such as Jon Rahm and Tyrell Hatton will make that task more difficult.
McIlroy could also finish top of the European table in terms of majors won. He is currently level with Faldo on six major victories but still trails Harry Vardon who won seven major titles at the turn of the 20th century. If we take Justin Rose as an example, McIlroy could still be competing for majors a decade from now so surely it is only a matter of time before two more fall his way.
He will already be planning his defence of the Masters for 2027, no golfer before has won that tournament back-to-back-to-back and McIlroy has the opportunity to make more history should he conquer Augusta once again.
This is one that is more difficult to define. It is something outside of McIlroy’s control, it’s a story that will be grown and developed by the generations of golfers to come, the ones just starting out and being inspired by seeing McIlroy on his knees in tears at Augusta, defying the hostile American crowds at Bethpage in New York, honouring Montgomerie’s own legacy in Dubai and paying an emotional tribute to his ill father Gerry.
Legacy is built not just in numbers but in moments. Moments of inspiration, of class, of jubliation and of despair. Seve Ballesteros, another name well placed in the debate of Europe’s greatest, excelled at them. So much so, the memory of his triumphs and legacy inspired the 2012 Miracle of Medinah and Europe’s great Ryder Cup comeback of which McIlroy played a crucial role.
McIlroy has already built up a series of defining moments across his career, both good and bad. His collapse on the final day of the 2011 Masters when leading the field, flying away to victory at the US Open in the same year, Ryder Cup partnerships with Graeme McDowell (2010 and 2012), Ian Poulter (2012, 2014, 2018, 2021) and Tommy Fleetwood (2023, 2025), the aforementioned Masters victory in 2025.
All these moments and more have built the story of McIlroy’s captivating 20-year career. He has already cemented his place amongst Europe’s best ever golfers and before he is done he will stand out as the greatest of them all.
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies
Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in
Reported by independent.co.uk.
Read Original Report at independent.co.uk ↗
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share your opinion!