I Offered to Treat My Mom to a Thanksgiving Meal Out. Then She Told Me What She Actually Expected.
Light Dark Auto Photo illustration by Slate. Photo by Getty Images Plus. Comment Copy Link Share Gift Story You have remaining gift available this month. This gift link is valid through . There was an error with your gift link. Please try again. Copy link Link copied! Only Slate Plus members can gift Slate stories. Become a member to share 10 free articles a month.Become a Plus Member Comment Copy Link Share Gift Story You have remaining gift available this month. This gift link is valid through . There was an error with your gift link. Please try again. Copy link Link copied! Only Slate Plus members can gift Slate stories. Become a member to share 10 free articles a month.Become a Plus Member Pay Dirt is Slateâs money advice column. Have a question? Send it to Kristin and Ilyce here. (Itâs anonymous!)
My wife and I are in much better financial shape than my sister, âAlly.â This is 100 percent due to the choices, both personal and financial, that my sister has made throughout her life. Then earlier this year, I learned my mom had been helping Ally and her adult children so they didnât âsuffer,â and her own money ran out. Mom had to sell her house and move into a one-bedroom subsidized retirement apartment. This has put a wrench in the normal family Thanksgiving, which my mom usually hosts.
It has always been expected that we (me, my wife, and kids) make the four-hour trip down to my momâs house for the holidays. (My mom doesnât like to drive long distances, though she has since sold her car, and Ally has never owned anything reliable enough to make the trip.)
But now mom says she canât host in her small apartment. She also says Ally isnât capable of cooking a full Thanksgiving dinner, so she suggested we all go to a local restaurant that is having a Thanksgiving Day buffet. I said, âThat sounds fine, I will cover the cost of your meal.â My mom said, âActually you will need to cover the cost of all the meals, as your sister canât afford to pay for her and her kids (along with the kidsâ significant others.)â I said, âI donât think so, she can cover her own familyâs cost.â My mom said, âWell, you can afford it, she canât.â
Can I? Maybe. I am already fed up that when I visit my mom and take her out for lunch, my sister shows up expecting me to also cover her bill. Plus, there is a big difference between spending $50 on lunch and dropping $400+ on taking the whole family out to a buffet. So I said that I would cover the cost of a couple of gas station pizzas and we can eat them at my sisterâs house. My mom said, âThat is an unacceptable Thanksgiving meal.â I then said, âIt is also unacceptable what my sister has done to you and herself financially to put you both in the position you are in.â My mom then said, âIt is unacceptable the way you are always holding your financial success over your sisterâs head and are unwilling to help when she needs it.â
As I said before, my sisterâs choices have put her in the position she is in at the moment. If I would âhelpâ her when she needs it, it would be ALL THE TIME. I told my mom to forget about us coming down for Thanksgiving. I said that my family would come down on a weekend, take her out to lunch, and if Ally shows up she will be paying her own way as I am done footing her bill each and every time I visit.
Well, my sister texted me and said I ruined the family and that I should be ashamed of myself for not spreading the wealth. She said if it was up to her, she would ban me from visiting my mom. Then a day later, I got a text from my mom saying that I should forget about coming to visit until I rethink my actions.
Am I in the wrong here? Yes, my wife and I are OK financially (solid middle class), but spending several hundred dollars to feed my sister and her family is something we really canât afford.
Whenever anyone sets boundaries for the first time, thereâs usually pushback. Thatâs whatâs happening here. But youâre not wrong to refuse to pay for everyoneâs Thanksgiving. This holiday, in particular, is about sharing, with everyone contributing. Your sisterâs family is made up of adults, and âyou can afford itâ isnât the same as âyou owe it to us.â
The problem is you didnât just set a boundary. You also threw a couple of punches. The gas station pizza offer and the crack about what your sister has done to your mom were bound to land as insults, and now the fight is about your tone instead of your finances.
So separate the two. Call your momâdonât textâand apologize. Not for what you meant, but for how you said it. Something like: âMom, Iâm sorry. I was frustrated and got sarcastic, and that wasnât fair to you. But I canât afford to pay for everyone every time weâre together, and I need you to understand that.â
Then offer her something real. Many grocery stores sell fully cooked Thanksgiving dinners that feed a crowd for far less than a restaurant buffet. Buy one, bring it to your sisterâs house, and ask her family to handle the sides, drinks, or dessert. Your mom gets her holiday, everyone eats a real Thanksgiving dinner, and youâre contributing generously without picking up every tab.
If that isnât going to fly, you can still spend the day with your mom and pay for her meal somewhere. Ally doesnât get to ban you from seeing your mother, no matter what she says in a text.
And if you all do make it to a restaurant after all, decide in advance what youâre paying for, and then say it before anyone orders: âIâm treating Mom today.â Saying it upfront is much easier than fighting over the check.
Iâm sorry that your mother has already given away her financial security to keep Ally afloat. Setting boundaries is one way to keep from following her down that path.
My stepdaughter Lydia, 13, has asked to be in the delivery room when I give birth to her little sister this January. Lydia has seen a delivery video in a class and is a mature, grounded young woman. My husband, her mom, and I all think this would be a good experience for Lydia. I will be clothed in a loose-fitting gown when I deliver, but Lydia will see my âprivate parts.â For this reason, Lydiaâs inclusion in the delivery horrifies our families and many friends.
Slate relies on advertising to support our journalism. If you value our work, please disable your ad blocker. If you want to block ads but still support Slate, consider subscribing.
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share your opinion!