Good CV not a governing philosophy: Rethinking the technocrat in Nigerian politics
Every election cycle in Nigeria brings with it a familiar conversation about the kind of people we want in government. When the economy struggles, public institutions underperform and policies fail to produce the desired results, the call for technocrats becomes louder. Nigerians increasingly want people with professional qualifications, relevant experience and a demonstrable understanding of the sectors they are appointed to manage. There is a growing belief that bringing accomplished professionals into government could help address some of the countryโs persistent governance challenges.
It is an argument worth making, and one I strongly support. However, I think we need to approach the conversation with a little more consideration. While Nigeria undoubtedly needs more qualified people in government, we must also recognise that professional success does not automatically translate into the ability to govern. A good CV is not a governing philosophy, and an impressive academic or professional background does not necessarily make someone an effective public administrator.
The danger is that, in our understandable frustration with the political class, we may have started treating technocrats as an automatic solution to the problems of governance. We assume that because someone has excelled in a particular profession, they will naturally excel in public office. That assumption deserves closer examination.
There is a difference between understanding a subject, managing an institution and delivering results. These are related responsibilities, but they require different capabilities. An accomplished medical professional may understand healthcare delivery but may not necessarily have the experience required to manage a complex health system. An economist may understand fiscal policy but may not have the administrative experience to manage a large government ministry. Similarly, a distinguished academic may have extensive knowledge of the education sector without necessarily possessing the leadership and management skills required to reform an education system.
This does not diminish the value of their expertise. Rather, it reinforces the need to be more deliberate about the people we appoint to public office.
Consider some of the challenges confronting Nigeria. Our healthcare system requires people who understand health financing, human resource management, service delivery and public health systems. Our education sector needs leadership that understands not only educational policy but also learning outcomes, teacher development, institutional management and the realities of access to quality education. Our agricultural sector requires people who appreciate the relationship between food production, agricultural financing, irrigation, storage, processing and market access. The power sector requires an understanding of engineering, energy economics, electricity markets and infrastructure financing.
These are complex sectors that cannot be managed effectively through political enthusiasm alone. They require people with the relevant knowledge and experience to understand the problems, identify workable solutions and oversee their implementation.
Unfortunately, political appointments in Nigeria have often been influenced by considerations that have little to do with the actual demands of the offices being filled. Political loyalty, party affiliations, regional considerations, personal relationships and the need to accommodate influential interests can all feature in the appointment process. While political considerations have their place in a democratic system, they should not consistently take precedence over competence and the ability to deliver.
A ministerial appointment should not be treated as a reward for political loyalty or an opportunity to accommodate individuals who have contributed to an electoral victory. It is a public responsibility, and the person appointed must possess the capabilities required to discharge that responsibility.
However, we must also be careful not to confuse international exposure with administrative competence. Having worked with the United Nations, the World Bank, international development organisations or prestigious institutions abroad can provide valuable experience. Yet, working within an established organisation with defined systems and resources is not necessarily the same as managing a government institution with its own administrative, financial and political complexities.
The same applies to academic qualifications. A doctorate, several professional certifications or an impressive educational history should not automatically make someone suitable for a ministerial position. What matters is whether the individual can apply their knowledge, lead people, manage resources, navigate institutional challenges and translate policy objectives into tangible results.
There are professionals who are excellent in their fields but may not necessarily possess the temperament or administrative capacity required for public office. Some are brilliant at identifying problems but less effective at managing the processes required to resolve them. Others may have extensive technical knowledge but struggle with stakeholder engagement, institutional coordination or the practical realities of implementation.
This is why the selection of technocrats must go beyond professional credentials. We should be looking for people who combine relevant expertise with leadership ability, sound judgment, integrity and a record of getting things done.
Equally, the conversation should not become an argument that politicians have no place in managing public institutions. Politics and professional competence are not mutually exclusive. There are politicians with considerable knowledge, experience and an excellent understanding of the sectors they oversee. There are also professionals who have successfully transitioned into public service and demonstrated that they can combine technical expertise with effective leadership.
The issue is not whether someone comes from a political or professional background. It is whether they are qualified for the responsibilities attached to the office they occupy.
Presidents and governors must therefore become more intentional about the people they appoint. Before filling a ministerial or commissioner position, there should be a serious consideration of the challenges within that ministry and the experience required to address them. The appointment process should prioritise relevant professional knowledge, administrative experience, leadership capacity and a demonstrable understanding of the sector.
It is also important to recognise that appointing the right person is only part of the solution. Even the most capable technocrat will struggle in an environment where institutions are weak, resources are inadequate, decisions are constantly disrupted and accountability is limited. Good leadership must be accompanied by functional systems, competent civil servants, reliable data and the institutional support necessary to deliver results.
We should also begin to question why political parties do not place greater emphasis on professional competence when identifying people for public office. The search for capable leadership should not begin only after an election has been won. It should be reflected in candidate selection, party manifestos and the quality of people being presented to Nigerians as potential leaders.
As we approach the 2027 general elections, this conversation becomes particularly important. Nigerians should look beyond political slogans and promises of new appointments. We should ask what kind of people aspiring leaders intend to bring into government, what qualifications they will consider and whether those appointments will be based on the actual responsibilities of the offices involved.
We should not be impressed simply because a prospective minister has an impressive biography or has occupied prominent positions in the past. We should be interested in what that individual has achieved, the institutions they have managed, the challenges they have addressed and the results they have delivered.
Ultimately, the argument for more technocrats in government should not be reduced to the belief that professionals are inherently better than politicians. It should be about recognising that the responsibilities of government require knowledge, experience, sound judgement and the ability to deliver. Political affiliation should never become a substitute for these qualities.
Nigeria needs more people who understand the problems they are appointed to solve. It needs people who can combine professional knowledge with the ability to manage institutions, work with others and deliver meaningful results. It needs political leaders who understand that public appointments are not personal favours but decisions with consequences for millions of people.
A good CV may open the door to public office, but it cannot, on its own, guarantee effective leadership. What matters is what the individual can do with the opportunity and whether Nigerians can see the difference in their everyday lives.
That is the standard we should begin to demand from those entrusted with governing our country.
Join Daily Trust WhatsApp Community For Quick Access To News and Happenings Around You.
Reported by dailytrust.com.
Read Original Report at dailytrust.com โ
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share your opinion!