‘We were terrified of him’: Neighbours reveal chilling encounter with man accused of running down Helen Haines just days before attack – after years of alleged threats and intimidation

By JONICA BRAY, SENIOR NEWS REPORTER, AUSTRALIA

Published: 00:10 EDT, 20 October 2026 | Updated: 00:15 EDT, 20 October 2026

The man accused of deliberately running down Victorian MP Helen Haines had allegedly terrorised his neighbours for years, threatening residents and even running over a family dog.

Brendan Nugent, 43, was arrested outside the independent MP’s electorate office in Wangaratta on Monday after allegedly using his four-wheel drive to ram the 65-year-old against another vehicle twice.

Dr Haines suffered catastrophic injuries in the attack and was rushed to hospital, where she underwent emergency surgery.

It has since been confirmed the independent MP for Indi lost a leg and remains in a critical condition as surgeons try to save her second leg.

Now, the Daily Mail can reveal that Nugent has been the subject of repeated police callouts over his alleged volatile behaviour, with neighbours claiming they have lived in fear for years.

Residents in the small rural community of Tarrawingee, north-east Victoria, have described chilling threats, incoherent screaming and an incident in which Nugent allegedly ran over and killed a neighbour’s dog.

‘Some of the neighbours have had to take out AVOs against him,’ one resident told Daily Mail.

‘He was right up in their face and screaming. He threatened to kill one man and he also ran over and killed their dog.

Federal MP Helen Haines has lost a leg and remains in a critical condition after an alleged deliberate attack outside her Wangaratta electorate office

Brendan Nugent, 43, from nearby Tarrawingee, remains in police custody over the incident. No charges had been laid as of Tuesday afternoon

‘We have been really scared for years. We live in the middle of nowhere and I still lock my doors because of Brendan.’

The neighbour, who did not want to be named for fear of retribution, claimed Nugent had been taken away by police on numerous occasions and admitted to the Kerferd psychiatric unit at Northeast Health Wangaratta.

She also claimed she had been told by authorities that Nugent suffered from schizophrenia and used marijuana to ease his symptoms.

According to the neighbour, police were familiar with Nugent following years of complaints about loud music, screaming and aggressive behaviour.

‘He blasts out heavy metal music night and day, screaming across the whole valley, and that’s when we know he is on one and we are careful then.

‘If we come across him, he screams at us and says we are evil.

‘It has got to the point where we have all had to drive our kids up to the school bus because they are scared of him.

‘The thing is, for the last two months he has been quiet and that’s the longest time we have had without the noise and him screaming incoherent rants.’

Nugent’s neighbours told Daily Mail they have been ‘terrified’ of him for years

But she said the relative peace ended just days before Nugent was arrested over the attack on Dr Haines.

‘Last week, my husband came across him in the bushes and he jumped out yelling, “Bad things have happened here,” over and over, and we knew we had to watch out again.’

On Monday afternoon, Nugent allegedly drove his white Toyota LandCruiser into Wangaratta, where Dr Haines was retrieving items from the boot of her car outside her electorate office on Murphy Street.

Witnesses said the driver made a U-turn before allegedly ramming the MP against her vehicle, reversing and striking her a second time.

Local barber Ricky Jefferies rushed to the scene and confronted Nugent, who allegedly had a knife.

Mr Jefferies managed to disarm and restrain him until police arrived.

On Tuesday morning, it was confirmed that Dr Haines had lost a leg due to injuries sustained.

The neighbour described Nugent as a loner who spent much of his time by the creek on his rural property and had not received visitors in years.

‘He’d go to Coles and take his dog with him, but other than that he never really left and no one has ever been to see him.

‘He doesn’t have a job, never has as long as we have known him. He couldn’t hold one down. He is not coherent most of the time.

‘His parents bought him the house but they don’t come and see him and it’s a pigsty. I have never been inside but you can see it’s a mess.’

She said Nugent had been easier to approach when she and her husband first moved to the area about six years ago.

‘When we first moved here he was a little more coherent then, still not easy to deal with but you could make some sense out of him.

‘My husband would speak to him when he saw him and noticed his grass was long and asked if he wanted us to put a cow in.

‘He got really angry and snapped that he didn’t eat animals.’

Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article.