Apprenticeship Is A Competitive Advantage Hiding In Plain Sight

This voice experience is generated by AI. Learn more.This voice experience is generated by AI. Learn more.By Katie Breault is Chief Delivery Officer of YUPRO Placement and leader in skills-first hiring and workforce strategy.

gettyMost businesses are feeling the limits of traditional hiring. The World Economic Forum reports that 63% of employers identify skills gaps as a major barrier to transforming their organizations, while employers expect 39% of workers’ core skills to change by 2030.

Organizations are competing for experienced candidates, while trying to develop early-career employees without always having the time or structure to do it well. Many are still searching the same narrow talent pools using the same credentials, filters and hiring assumptions.

Apprenticeship offers a different approach. It gives employers a structured way to develop talent around the capabilities their businesses actually need. Yet many organizations remain on the sidelines.

The hesitation is understandable. Most business leaders don’t question whether apprenticeship can work. They question whether their organization has the time, capacity and infrastructure to implement it successfully. The obstacle is often not talent or interest, but execution.

Apprenticeship can expand the available talent pool by having employers identify people with the aptitude to learn, rather than competing exclusively for candidates who already possess every desired qualification. It also creates a stronger connection between training and business need. Employees develop capabilities they are expected to apply on the job, while learning the systems, expectations and operating environment of the organization itself.

The challenge is making all of that work.

Employers must recruit candidates, design training, onboard employees, engage managers, coordinate instruction, provide coaching, navigate payroll and compliance requirements, measure performance and ultimately create pathways into long-term employment. In a 2025 report, the U.S. Government Accountability Office identified administrative burden as a primary barrier to expanding employer participation in apprenticeship. Meanwhile, U.S. Department of Labor research has found employers can receive approximately $1.40 to $1.90 in benefits for every dollar invested in apprenticeship.

The opportunity, then, is to create an operating model that allows apprenticeship to function as part of the business, rather than alongside it.

The strongest apprenticeship programs begin with a clearly defined workforce challenge. Perhaps a critical role is consistently difficult to fill, recurring turnover may be creating disruption and repeated hiring costs, or an organization may routinely find employees with potential but lack a structured way to develop them.

Looking at apprenticeship through the lens of such problems changes the conversation. It moves beyond a workforce development initiative and becomes a practical response to an operating problem.

An employer struggling to hire experienced data analysts, for example, may not need every new employee to arrive fully formed. It may benefit more from people with strong fundamentals who can learn the company’s systems and grow into increasingly complex work.

Apprenticeship becomes a deliberate process for moving people from potential to performance.

For apprenticeship to scale, it must be easier for organizations to execute. Managers should not be expected to design training, coach apprentices, oversee compliance, track progress and carry the program’s administrative responsibilities on top of their existing workloads. Their focus should be helping apprentices apply new skills, providing meaningful feedback and supporting performance.

Other responsibilities can be shared across a broader ecosystem. Workforce partners, apprenticeship intermediaries, training providers, staffing organizations and employer-of-record models can provide infrastructure and assume much of the operational work that prevents companies from getting started.

One example is Checkr.org, the community impact arm of people data platform Checkr. The organization works to expand employment opportunities for justice-impacted individuals through fair chance hiring. Its Catalyst Apprenticeship Program shows how an ecosystem approach can reduce friction for employers. Different partners handle specific responsibilities, including identifying and preparing talent, apprenticeship registration, employment administration, coaching and support. That infrastructure allows participating employers, such as Lyft and Aramark, to focus more directly on integrating apprentices into their teams and developing them on the job.

Like any strategic investment, apprenticeship should be evaluated by business outcomes.

Are employees becoming productive more quickly? Are they staying longer? Is the program reducing vacancy pressure in difficult-to-fill roles? Is it lowering costs associated with repeated hiring and turnover?

Measuring outcomes consistently makes apprenticeship easier to improve, support and scale. More importantly, it places apprenticeship where it belongs: alongside other investments intended to improve business performance.

Organizations do not need to launch an enterprise-wide apprenticeship program on day one. Start with one role family, business unit or recurring workforce challenge. Define success, support the managers involved, measure results, and use what you learn to expand with greater confidence.

This approach reduces risk while giving leaders concrete evidence they can evaluate through performance, retention, productivity, manager experience and long-term workforce needs.

We have seen this approach work with one Fortune 500 employer that began with just five apprentices across several high-demand functions. As the organization gained experience with the model, the program expanded. A total of 27 apprentices ultimately completed the program, with 90% accepting full-time positions with the company. Starting small allowed the employer to test the model against its own workforce needs before expanding it.​

Skills will continue changing, and experienced talent will remain competitive. Organizations that rely exclusively on external hiring will remain vulnerable whenever the labor market cannot supply the capabilities they need quickly enough.

Apprenticeship provides another option: develop those capabilities instead of waiting for them to appear in the labor market. The result is an organization that is less dependent on finding the perfect candidate because it has become much better at honing in-house talent.

Take an honest look at where the current hiring model is falling short. In an increasingly competitive talent market, developing people for the roles you need may prove more sustainable than continually competing to hire and buy experienced talent from somewhere else.​

Forbes Business Council is the foremost growth and networking organization for business owners and leaders. Do I qualify?