Furore over CBN’s cash reserve requirement

    0
    58

    THE business outlook for most of the operators in the bureau de change and other sectors has been anything but smooth in recent times, no thanks to the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN)’s cash reserve requirement policy regime.

    For some time, the monetary tightening measures introduced by the CBN have generated concerns. The measures include the increase in Monetary Policy Rate (MPR) benchmark interest rate by 275 basis point to 12 per cent, the reduction in the net provision which banks hold as reserves is up from 5 per cent to 7 per cent, and the increase in the Cash Reserve Requirement (CRR) of banks from 4 to 8 per cent. Of all these, it’s the cash reserve requirement that has provoked much indignation among industry watchers.

    Mr. Adeboye Adenuga, the Managing Director, Dambiz Bureau De Change Limited, is already feeling the impact of this policy.

    He approached his bank, one of the new generation banks, for a loan last week but was required to pay what he called “outrageous interest rate.”

    Like Adenuga, a lot of businessmen who rely on bank credits to drive their business have faced disappointment in recent times.

    Speaking on this development, Adenuga said: “It cuts across different sectors. Nobody is left out. We are left with no option but to seek alternative source of funding if we must remain in the business.”

    CRR is the proportion of cash which banks are expected to keep in their vaults. This implies that banks would hold more cash in their reserves, there by affecting the level of funds they would release as loans to the investing public. With the increase in CRR, industry observers have continued to predict a tough time for the operators in the economy.

     

    Impact of policy

     

    On the adverse effect of the policy, analysts said the development would weigh down the liquidity position of banks as well as affect their capacity to lend to borrowers significantly.

    They further argued that the upward review of the monetary policy rate, runs contrary to the decision of the CBN to maintain price stability and further send strong signals to the foreign exchange market. They contended that any attempt by banks to hold up some cash, would affect the major commanding heights of the economy, including the oil and gas, maritime, manufacturing to mention just a few.

    Speaking on the issue, the Executive Secretary, Association of Foods Beverages and Tobacco Companies, Mr. Aderemi Adegboyega said manufacturers would soon feel the impacts of the increase in the CRR. Adegboyega said the increase in CRR signifies more problems for the real sector, arguing that the issue is going to have ripple effects on all aspects of the economy.

    He said: “The banks’ liquidity position is going to be worsened by the increase in cash reserve requirement. Now that CRR has been moved up, it means banks would keep more and give out little cash to the investors. When this happens, the manufacturers would be starved of funds and would not be able to produce optimally. Already, the lending rates to the real sector operators stand between 23 and 26 per cent. Some banks charge higher, after factoring other costs into it. There is an indication that banks would move up the lending rates, since they would be contending with small cash. The issue would aggravate the situation of the real sector operators. They would suffer low capacity utilisation, down size, and increase the cost of goods.”

    He said the issue is a vicious cycle, adding that formal and informal operators in the economy would be affected. He listed the traders, transporters, salary earners, among others, as targeted groups who are bound to suffer the bitter pills of this new policy regime.

    Echoing similar views, Dr Austin Nweze of the Lagos Business School, said the effects of increase in banks’ cash reserve requirement would soon be felt in the country.

    Nweze said banks have increased all lending rates as a result of increase in MPR, adding that upward review of CRR would push the lending rates further.

    He said when banks keep more money in their reserves; there would be little funds to give out as loans to investors.

    He said: “At present, Nigerians are still feeling the harsh effects of the economy. Salaries are small in many companies, while others are not paying regularly. The increase in lending rates for consumers’ loan means more hardships for them. Many customers would not be able to approach the banks for soft loans because of the increase in lending rates, and that means that they would not be able to meet most of their domestic obligations.”

    He said the increase in lending rates would discourage many manufacturers from borrowing.

    “With CRR now 8 per cent, many firms would find it difficult to give out huge loans to customers. Inability of companies to access sufficient loans for their operations means low productivity. Based on this, we should be expecting a gale of retrenchment in most companies, especially those that produce consumables. This would further increase the pressure on the economy”, he added.

    Giving his own submission, a former General Manager, Heritage Securities Limited, Mr. Tayo Bello, said there is nothing wrong in the decision of the CBN to contract the money supply, but however warned of the danger of reducing the capacity of banks to lend to the economy.

    View post:
    Furore over CBN’s cash reserve requirement