“American Idol” Finalists Judge Lawyers

2/23/2011 12:55 AM PST by TMZ Staff  

There was a secret competition behind-the-scenes at “American idol“‘ last month — but this time the wannabes were three prestigious law firms fighting for a job … and it was up to the singers to decide their fate.

TMZ has learned … “Idol” execs gave the top 40 finalists the opportunity to select a law firm that would represent the singers … to review and negotiate the A.I. contract the singers must now sign.

We’re told three firms gave their best pitches to the group — and after the presentations, the singers had to vote by a show of hands on which firm would get the job … majority rules.

In the end, the gang picked Craig Marshall and Gary L. Gilbert (see above) from the mega-firm of Manatt, Phelps & Phillips — a firm which boasts huge clients like Coca-Cola, Sony and The Eagles. 

Hopefully, the losing firms were treated to a musical montage on their way out.

Tags: American Idol, American Idol 2011