INDEPENDENT NEWSPAPERS
Tracy Stein took her Mercedes Benz AMG convertible to Mercedes Benz Northcliff. The dealership crashed the car, and later said it was not liable as Stein was not insured. Photo: Itumeleng English
If you send your car in for a service and the dealership crashes it while taking it on a test drive, you could be liable for the cost of its repair.
This is exactly the situation a Joburg woman has found herself in after she took her car to Mercedes Benz Northcliff.
After doing some work to the car, the dealership crashed it, causing an estimated R300 000 in damage.
Tracy Stein, 41, took her Mercedes Benz AMG convertible to have new brake pads fitted the day before delivering it to a buyer. Her business was not doing well and she was battling to keep up with the monthly instalments of R28 000.
So, two months before finding a buyer, she parked it safely and stopped paying her insurance.
Stein’s 20-year-old son Kayle dropped the car off for her and was given a form to sign. Later that rainy afternoon, Stein received a call from the dealership. The person test driving her car had skidded off the road and hit a tree while trying to avoid an oncoming car in his lane.
A Mercedes Benz dealership crashed Tracy Stein’s Mercedes Benz AMG convertible, and later said it was not liable as Stein was not insured. Photo: Itumeleng English
“They told me not to worry and that they accepted full responsibility. They gave me a courtesy car. Later they asked me about insurance, saying my insurer must fix it and they will pay the excess,” Stein recalled.
But when it turned out that Stein did not have cover, Mercedes refused to fix the car at their expense and asked for their courtesy car back.
When Stein complained, they produced the document Kayle had signed. It carried a disclaimer indemnifying the dealership from any responsibility for damage.
The terms and conditions added that the customer must have insurance and couldn’t make claims against the dealership if the insurer failed to pay “any amount for any reason whatsoever”.
Kayle, however, said what he signed for was to acknowledge scratches on the front bumper and rim, and not for the dealership to absolve itself from blame.
Now Stein has approached a lawyer, intending to sue.
“They say my son signed the document, but I did not give them permission to crash my car,” she seethed.
The dealership says they never promised to repair Stein’s car.
Ralph Nortje, chief operating officer for Mercedes Benz Gauteng West, said it was not policy for dealerships to ask clients whether they had insurance, as the law stated that every car financed by the bank be insured.
He said dealerships were only covered against theft, hijacking and fire.
“If the car had been insured this would have not been an issue at all. The risk is with the customer if they sign the document saying they have insurance, whereas they don’t.
“She broke the law (by not having insurance) and now suddenly we are the bad people. The disclaimer waives our responsibility because the customers should have been insured,” Nortje said.
The dealership said they had never had a problem like this before, because all of their other customers had been insured.
Nortje said brakes were a safety critical item, meaning the car had to be driven and checked after they were fitted. This would not have been done, he said, had they been made aware of the fact that the car was not insured.
While some motor dealerships said they expected their clients to be insured, others said this was not a prerequisite.
Mark Chapman of Lazarus Centurion, a Volvo dealership, said their clients didn’t have to have insurance as they were insured should anything happen to cars in their care.
Warren George, principal dealer at Auto Glen Motors, a BMW dealership, said they assumed that customers were insured.
Should this turn out not to be the case, he said his dealership would pay for a client’s car if it was damaged by them.
McCarthy VW Westgate’s service manager Paul Couto said they gave clients a document to sign, declaring that they had insurance.
What the experts say:
Prudence Moilwa of the National Consumer Commission said she could not get into the merits of the Stein case and pass judgment as it still had to be investigated.
However, she said, in terms of the Consumer Protection Act, a supplier must not carry out a transaction subject to terms and conditions that limited or exempted their liability in cases of loss attributed to gross negligence on their part.
According to Haydn Davies, a partner at law firm Webber Wentzel, the indemnity was not binding on Stein and she had a claim against the dealer for damages suffered.
Davies also said that if Kayle did not have authority to sign on his mother’s behalf, Stein would not be bound by the indemnity clause and Mercedes Benz could not rely on it.
However, Davies cautioned, the indemnity form probably stated that the person signing had to possess authority and that if this was not the case, the business was not liable.
“The effect of such a clause, assuming it was valid, would be that she would sue the dealership and the dealership (probably in effect, the dealership’s insurers) would seek to recover any damages paid to the owner from the son, flowing from his breach of warranty and giving of the indemnity.
“Assuming the son did have authority, the question that then arises is whether the indemnity is binding on the owner. On the current facts, because of the content of the CPA, I do not believe that it is binding,” Davies said. – The Star
