Rejoinder: “Supreme Court Is Wrong On Prisoner Franchise”

    0
    36

    On Friday 9th December, 2011 I read, on myjoyonline.com, an article written by Kwame Okoampa Ahoofe, Ph.D., under the title “Supreme Court is Wrong on Prisoner Franchise”. As the title of the article suggests, Professor Ahoofe sought to question the reasoning and wisdom which went to Supreme Court’s decision that citizens of Ghana who find themselves in prisons within the country have the right, just like their non-incarcerated compatriots, to vote in national elections.

    I have in the past read some other articles written by Professor Ahoofe on important national issues, and I think he has often done a pretty good job of discussing issues dispassionately and in a well-thought-out manner. For someone who is apparently domiciled outside the country to follow developments in Ghana and put his comments in writing as a contribution to the national discourse, he deserves to be commended.

    Having said that though, I think his article in which he chastised the Supreme Court for holding that prisoners have a right to vote in elections in this country was poorly researched, ill-thought-out and logically flawed. In this piece I challenge Professor Ahoofe’s opinion on the Supreme Court’s decision. I will set out the arguments he makes in his article and point how why they are flawed and ought to be rejected. But before that, I provide here a brief account of the case in which the Supreme Court held that prisoners have the right to vote and how the Court came to that conclusion.

    The Prisoners’ Voting Rights case

    Article 42 of the 1992 Constitution guarantees that all Ghanaians of eighteen (18) years and above and who are of sound mind have the right to register and to vote in elections held in this country. But of course before this right could be exercised, certain modalities have to be put in place. There for instance has to be an Electoral Commission which will conduct the elections, its powers have to be defined, constituencies have to be demarcated, and eligible voters have to be registered. Accordingly, apart from the Constitution there are other laws which regulate how all these modalities have to be put in place to enable Ghanaians exercise the right to vote. One of such laws is the Representation of the People Law, 1992 (PNDC Law 284).

    This law spells out, among others, how the Electoral Commission must go about with the creation of constituencies and the registration of voters. Section 7 of the Law provides that a person who is a citizen of Ghana and 18 years or above should be registered to vote in a particular constituency. According to the law, that constituency must be the constituency in which the person resides. As far as residency is concerned, the Law goes on to prescribe that the person seeking to register must have lived continuously in that area/constituency where he seeks to be registered for at least the six months immediately preceding the date of the registration. If a person has not lived in that constituency for those six months, he will be considered as a non-resident and can therefore not register in that particular constituency.

    The part of the Law which sparked controversy and led to the Supreme Court’s decision is Section 7(5). That section provides that “A person who is … detained in legal custody in any place shall not be treated as resident there for the purposes of this section”. What this means is that a person who is either a remand or convicted prisoner detained in a prison cannot register for the purposes of voting in an election in the constituency in which the prison is located. This is because the prison is legally not considered as a place of abode. To put it simply and bluntly, the prisoner is not considered to be a resident in the constituency in which the prison is located so he cannot register there for the purposes of voting in elections.

    The other devastating effect of the law is that, even if the prisoner is released (either on bail or on pardon) so that he could go to his constituency to register, he may still not qualify to be registered because, in most cases, he would have been away from that constituency for at least six months. And remember we earlier mentioned that a person who has not been living in his constituency for a period of six(6) months immediately preceding the date of registration is, under the law, a non-resident and is not entitled to be registered to vote in that constituency. So clearly, from whichever angle you looked at the Law, our brothers and sisters in prison could not be registered to vote; not in the prison because they are by law not “residents of the prison” and not back in their home constituencies even if they were released just to go and do that, because they would in most cases have been away for more than six months rendering them ineligible to register in those places too.

    It was this bizarre state of affairs which PNDC Law 284 had created in relation to prisoners’ right to vote that Mr Ahumah Ocansey (in his personal capacity as a citizen of Ghana) and the Center for Human Rights & Civil Liberties (CHURCIL) led by Mr Kojo Graham challenged before the Supreme Court in 2008 as being inconsistent with the 1992 Constitution. In a unanimous decision delivered on 23rd March, 2010 the Supreme Court upheld the arguments of the petitioners that the sections of PNDC Law 284 which denied prisoners the right to register and vote in national elections were inconsistent with the 1992 Constitution, particularly article 42 which guarantees for all Ghanaians the right to vote provided they are eighteen years or above and of sound mind.

    Chief Justice Georgina Wood, delivering the lead opinion of the Court, observed that “Prisons form part of Ghana’s territory. If a national census were to be ordered, prisoners would be counted, not discounted. Moreover prisoners do not lose other fundamental constitutional rights by virtue of their status or deprivation of their liberty, whether temporary or permanent.” The learned Chief Justice further observed that it is “extremely difficult to understand what constitutionally legitimate interest is served by the non-recognition of prisons as places of residence for the purposes of voter registration; even for those who have been convicted of high crime against the State, such as subversion or high treason. [That] even for those who attempt to derail the democratic process, voting remains an important means of teaching them democratic values.”

    It is on the basis of this decision allowing prisoners the right to register and vote in national elections that Professor Kwame Okoampa Ahoofe, chastises the highest Court of our Republic in his article the “Supreme Court is Wrong on Prisoner Franchise”. In the next few paragraphs I set out the arguments Professor Ahoofe makes in his article and expose the shallowness and fallacies in which they are clothed.

    Analysis of Professor Ahoofe’s Article

    The first thing I find worrying about Professor Ahoofe’s article is actually his decision to write and publish the said article. With all due respect to him, that decision was pre-mature and unwarranted. It is trite learning, and I am sure that being a Professor he knows or at the very least ought to know, that one can possibly not set out to analyze, let alone criticize, a work when one has not read the said work. This I believe is a basic rule which ought to guide any academic, researcher or writer who wants to be taken seriously. But it is unfortunate that the exact opposite is what the honorable Professor did in this case, namely, by attacking the wisdom and reasoning of the learned Justices of the Supreme Court without even bothering to find out what the judgment of the Court was about. In his own words: “since I am, of course, not privy to the exact details based upon which the Supreme Court arrived at its decision of permitting prison inmates access to the franchise, it is quite difficult to fathom the rationale and/or logic behind the same”.

    This is shocking indeed and by all indications smacks of academic ineptitude. Why would the honorable Professor want to subject a judgment of the Supreme Court of Ghana to such scathing attacks without first satisfying himself of the very grounds upon which the Court arrived at its decision? I do not think that in the face of his own admission it would be unfair to say that he did not even know what he was talking about. Indeed on the basis of this unpardonable failure alone, the Professor’s article and the arguments therein fall flat. But for the purpose of providing the Ghanaian public with the full picture of Professor Ahoofe’s erroneous criticisms of the Supreme Court I will proceed to deal with the substantive arguments in his article.

    For someone who did not even bother to read the judgment of the Court before criticizing it Professor Ahoofe claims, that “the recent ruling by the Ghanaian Supreme Court that prisoners have a right to vote in national elections, flagrantly violates the fundamental purpose for which the punitive and disciplinary institution of incarceration was established”. And that, “allowing prisoners to vote violates the very practically and historically meaningful purpose for which these societal offenders were immured, to begin with”.

    It is shocking to me that the honorable Professor suggests that for a country which is striving to achieve 21st Century standards of democracy, human rights and rule of law we should derail our efforts by adopting a criminal justice system reminiscent of the medieval ages. Clearly if the honorable Professor had done a bit of research on the development of criminal justice systems around world before deciding to criticize the Supreme Court, he would have discovered that the approach he wants us to adopt as far as prisoners rights are concerned has long been dumped in the garbage cans of history! See for instance the Eight Amendment of the United States Constitution: “Excessive bail shall not be required, nor excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted.” So as far back as 1791, America had taken the step to abolish the kind criminal justice system whose only aim is to inflict cruel and unusual punishments by adopting this Eight Amendment to their Constitution.

    Is it not bizarre therefore that in 2011, Professor Ahoofe would rather that we go back and pick what the democracies we look up to today discarded centuries ago?

    The world has changed, and so has criminal justice systems. The preferred approach the world over, now, is to de-emphasize the “infliction of punishment” on the prisoner and rather reform and rehabilitate him so that he could return to society as a responsible citizen. It is in line with this new approach to prisoners rights that the learned Chief Justice held that “even for those who attempt to derail the democratic process [and find themselves in prisons], voting remains an important means of teaching them democratic values”. Clearly if the honorable Professor had taken it upon himself to read the Court’s opinion and done a bit of research, he would have understood the Court and perhaps he would have come to a much more informed conclusion. He would also have realized that Ghana does not stand alone in this progressive development of allowing prisoners the right to vote. He would have known that at least in our own African backyard we have South Africa as an example.

    Professor Ahoofe goes on further to make a wild allegation, unsupported by any legal or scientific grounds, that “the Fourth-Republican Ghanaian Constitution clearly stipulates that the right to vote is a sacred privilege and trust unreservedly granted to Ghanaian citizens who are of sound mind, emotional and psychological poise and law-abiding. [And that] if the foregoing observation has validity, then it stands to reason that breakers of the law are by this very fact not responsible citizens and thus cannot be entrusted with the responsible exercising of the franchise. It also follows from the latter premise that breakers of the law may likely not be of sound mind.”

    First, he starts on the wrong premise that under the 1992 Fourth Republican Constitution, a person must have “emotional and psychological poise and [be] law-abiding” to qualify to vote. This makes me wonder whether the honorable Professor indeed averted his mind to article 42 of the 1992 Constitution before setting out to write his critique of the Supreme Court judgment he had not read either. For the avoidance of doubt this is what article 43 says: “Every citizen of Ghana of eighteen years of age or above and of sound mind has the right to vote and is entitled to be registered as a voter for the purposes of public elections and referenda”. Where in these unmistakable words of article 42 did Professor Ahoofe get his additional voter qualifications of “emotional and psychological poise and law-abiding” from?
    Indeed, even the Supreme Court which has the power to interpret the Constitution has always been cautious in not making the mistake of reading into the Constitution words which are not found there. So in the Republic v Fast Track High Court, Accra; ex parte Daniel [2001-2002] SCGLR 620 Prof.

    Kludze JSC (as he then was) cautioned his colleague Justices on the Supreme Court that: “Even in the area of statutory interpretation, we cannot amend a piece of legislation because we dislike its terms or because we suppose that the law giver was mistaken or unwise. Our responsibility is greater when we interpret the Constitution. We cannot and must not substitute our wisdom for the collective wisdom of the framers of the Constitution.”

    So even if the Supreme Court is cautioning itself against importation of words into the Constitution, in what capacity does Professor Ahoofe purport to add those additional voter qualifications to the unmistakable words of article 42?

    The other unfounded deduction Professor Ahoofe makes from his erroneous reading of article 42 and his so-called “emotional, psychological and law abiding” voter qualification is that persons in prison should not be allowed to vote because “breakers of the law may likely not be of sound mind”.

    Again on what scientific evidence does the Professor make these sweeping allegations? With all due respect, what are his competencies if any, in psychiatry or clinical psychology to enable him sit in judgment on the mental health of prisoners as he sought to do in his article? Besides, is he aware that in the prisons there are two categories of prisoners, namely convicted prisoners and remand prisoners? And does he also know that remand prisoners are those prisoners whose trial have not been completed and can therefore not be considered as law breakers because our Constitution presumes them to be innocent until proven guilty?

    And so even if for purposes of argument we go by his logic that all persons in prisons are lawbreakers and hence are likely to be of unsound mind, how does this logic apply to remand prisoners who are considered by our law as being innocent until proven guilty? Are they law breakers and therefore of unsound mind, on the authority of Professor Ahoofe, even though our Constitution says otherwise? I think the least said about this logic, any further, the better.

    Professor Ahoofe’ makes other claims which are equally unfounded, but I do not intend to bore you with long analysis of all of them. He claims, for instance, that instead of assuming jurisdiction on the matter brought before it, “the Court ought to have called for the matter to be put to a nationwide referendum come Election 2012.” Clearly, this is a further demonstration of the level of research the Professor did before he decided to write his critique on the Supreme Court decision.

    Had he taken pains to take even a cursory look at the 1992 Constitution, I am sure he would have come across a provision in article 130 which says that “the Supreme Court shall have exclusive original jurisdiction in – (a) all matters relating to the enforcement or interpretation of this Constitution; and (b) all matters arising as to whether an enactment was made in excess of the powers conferred on Parliament or any other authority or person by law or under this Constitution.” And if he had seen article 130, I am sure he would have kept his ill-advised “referendum recommendation” for the Supreme Court to himself. Because clearly, I do not see the basis on which Professor Ahoofe suggests that the Supreme Court ought to have abdicated its constitutional duty of interpreting and enforcing the Constitution in this matter when its jurisdiction had been properly invoked by the petitioners.

    Conclusion

    It is for the foregoing reasons that I take issue with Professor Okoampa Ahoofe’s article as being a fair and informed critique of the Supreme Court’s decision granting prisoners the right to register and vote in national elections. I believe that those of us who have the rare privilege of contributing to the national discourse by putting our opinions in the public domain owe it as a duty to our readers to give them a fair, accurate and well informed analysis of all the issues, particularly those that border on technical issues like the law. With all due respect, I do not think that Professor Ahoofe met this standard in his article “Supreme Court is Wrong on Prisoner Franchise” and it is for this reason that I have come up with this rejoinder to control the damage the honorable Professor caused through his mistaken criticism of the Supreme Court of this Republic.

    Christopher Nyinevi, chrislynk05@gmail.com (This article shall not be republished in any other medium, in full or in part, without the author’s authorization)