Feature: China In Ghana: Are we prepared to bargain?

    0
    43

    For many trade enthusiasts, a recent publication by the Daily Graphic indicating a spike in Chinese investments in Ghana was received with much fan fare. According to the Daily, Chinese investment capital in Ghana’s economy amounted to US$ 2.5 billion in the first three quarters of 2011.

    It was further reported that total investments is expected to rise to US$3.5 billion at year end, representing a 50 percent increase over the 2010 fiscal year.

    China’s economic engagement with Ghana is on a leap and bounds. Hardly a day goes by without a Chinese funded project being trumpeted somewhere in the country. A few days ago, the Brong Ahafo Regional Minister announced that China has expressed interest to undertake expansion of the Sunyani Water Supply System. In the days, weeks and months to come, China may sign further deals to construct a road, build a dam, a school or whatever project that tickles the government’s fancy.

    While most ordinary Ghanaians welcome Chinese projects as a good development, many of our traditional ‘development partners’ in the West are growing quite unease about the new romance developing between Ghana and China. The reason is simple. Westerners (the IMF, World Bank, donor agencies) think they know the path Ghana must follow in order to develop: liberalize markets, get prices right, promote democracy. And the West also thinks that they know what China is doing in resource-rich states like Ghana: offering gargantuan no-strings-attached loans in order to secure rights to natural resources.

    Like most African countries these days, our political and business elites have developed the propensity to view the Chinese as an “all-weather friend” to Ghana – a strategic partner, a reliable source of trade, loans and investments, and a hedge against Western domination. We have been seduced by the Chinese mantra that they are in our country to engage in a ‘win-win’ relationship unlike the Western imperialist who came earlier to pillage our natural resources and meddled in our political affairs. Our confidence in China has grown so strong that the Mills administration even managed to develop some balls to stick the middle finger to the IMF when the organization expressed misgivings about a US$ 3 billion loan the government intended to contract from its new found amore.

    As someone who advocates substituting foreign aid with trade and investments, I welcome trade with and investments from China as a useful resource in our capital accumulation efforts. However, we must not be complacent this time around in preparing adequately to enhance our negotiating position with the impending foreign power. As the saying goes “meet the new boss, same as the old boss”. We must not assume blindly that China is in Ghana to do Ghana’s bidding. China is in Ghana to advance Chinese national interest, period!

    We must be cognisant of the fact that our engagements with Beijing present huge opportunities as well as risks. Eager for infrastructural development and technological advancement but with limited supply of foreign exchange, Beijing presents an opportunity for us to leverage our resources – cocoa, gold, bauxite, diamond, oil etc – to attract concessionary loans from Chinese financial institutions. This should enable us to build our transport corridors, meet our energy demands, develop our health institutions, improve on education delivery etc. In return we can repay our Chinese friends with shipments of resources. For example, the Kufour administration agreed to repay China with cocoa in exchange for China’s construction of the Bui dam project in the Brong Ahafo Region.

    Nonetheless, loans from China pose some financial risks for us as a nation, especially if Chinese companies are automatically awarded infrastructural contracts without competitive bidding. In addition, we risk losing out if the prices of our resources, the basis of the loan repayments, are set in advance given that commodity prices have a tendency to fluctuate. Moreover, there has always been a concern about the laxity of the environmental and social safeguards of Chinese projects. Most importantly, Chinese companies have a bad reputation of bringing their own workforce – averaging twenty percent of the total manpower required by projects – thus reducing employment opportunities for Ghanaians. Salaries and working conditions for the locals that are lucky enough to be employed is often meagre and below labour standards.

    To mitigate these dangers, we must for instance guard against unfair pricing by depositing the earnings of natural resource exports into escrow accounts and assess their value at that moment without fixing the prices in advance. Our trade negotiators and loan contractors must be hard and better-informed bargainers and this requires competent individuals, not government bootlickers. Secondly, we must make it a requirement for Chinese companies to subcontract approximately 35 percent of any project to Ghanaian firms.

    Thirdly, we must demand at least four competitive bidding from Chinese companies for every project they plan to undertake and we must also place a 15 percent labour cap on Chinese nationals undertaking any construction project in Ghana. Finally, we must bargain for at least 2 percent of the cost of each infrastructural project to be spent on training Ghanaians in areas of management and technical expertise.

    We must be vigilant in ensuring that the next fifty years will not be like the last and that oil must not become another cocoa, gold or diamond. Neither should we allow China, ‘the new boss’, to become like Europe, ‘the old boss’. Ghana must become ‘the boss’ of Ghana’s natural resources for a change. This time around, the proceeds of our natural resources must directly result in significant improvements in the life of all Ghanaians.

    Natural resources can be a catalyst to prosperity. We see evidence of that in places like Botswana, United Arab Emirates, Norway and Canada. But to follow the example of these countries, we must first develop our capacity to maintain adequate control over those resources. Let our financial and trade negotiators at the Finance Ministry and the Bank of Ghana learn a thing or two from our market women; bargain like your life depend on it!

    *Frank S. Debrah is a graduate of Development Economics at Simon Fraser University in Vancouver. He is currently a staff member in the Government of British Columbia, Canada. E-mail: fsd@sfu.ca